Guide · Gold Coins
American Gold Eagle vs Gold Buffalo: Which Should You Buy?
Both coins contain exactly one troy ounce of pure gold, so their melt value is the same. The American Gold Eagle is 22-karat gold alloyed with silver and copper, which makes it heavier and harder to scratch. The American Gold Buffalo is .9999 fine 24-karat gold, which some buyers prefer but which marks more easily.
For most buyers the deciding factor is simply which one costs less per ounce at the moment you buy. The rest of this guide covers the cases where the other differences matter.
Gold Eagle and Gold Buffalo side by side
| American Gold Eagle (1 oz) | American Gold Buffalo | |
|---|---|---|
| Pure gold | 1 troy oz | 1 troy oz |
| Gross weight | 33.931 g | 31.108 g |
| Purity | 22K, 91.67% gold | 24K, .9999 fine |
| Other metals | Silver and copper | Essentially none |
| Made since | 1986 | 2006 |
| Fractional sizes | 1/2, 1/4 and 1/10 oz | Check what your dealer stocks |
| Scratch resistance | Better | Softer, shows handling marks |
The table below prices both coins at today's spot. Expect the melt figures to match, because the gold inside is identical.
| Coin | Years | Metal content | Melt value | × face |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1986–present | 1.0000 oz gold | $3,538.62 | 70.8× | |
| 2006–present | 1.0000 oz gold | $3,537.41 | 70.7× |
Melt value = metal content × today’s spot price. It is not what a dealer pays (usually less) or a collector’s price (often more).
You can read the full specs on our American Gold Eagle page and the Gold Buffalo page.
What 22K and 24K mean in your hand
Pure gold is soft. Mints alloy it to make coins that survive handling. The Gold Eagle adds silver and copper, bringing the coin to 33.931 g so that the gold part still weighs one troy ounce. That extra 2.8 grams is the price of toughness, not a bonus or a shortfall.
The Buffalo skips the alloy. It's close to one troy ounce on the scale, and nearly every bit of it is gold. Some buyers like the clean idea of "four nines" purity. Others don't care, because they're buying an ounce of gold either way.
In practice the difference shows up in two places:
- Handling. A Buffalo dropped on a counter or rubbed against another coin picks up marks more readily. For bullion that mostly matters to the next buyer's eye, not to its gold value.
- Color. 24K gold has a deeper yellow tone. 22K looks a bit warmer or redder because of the copper. Neither is a sign of quality.
For the full breakdown of the Eagle's alloy and each fractional size, see Gold Eagle weight and purity explained.
How to compare premiums properly
Dealers sell both coins above spot. The premium covers minting, distribution and the dealer's margin, and it moves with demand. One month the Eagle may be cheaper, another month the Buffalo. Don't assume either is always the bargain.
Worked example. Say gold spot is $4,000 an ounce and a dealer lists:
- 1 oz Gold Eagle at $4,220: premium $220, or 5.5% over spot.
- 1 oz Gold Buffalo at $4,180: premium $180, or 4.5% over spot.
Buy ten, and the Buffalos save you $400 at that dealer on that day. Then check what the same dealer pays when buying each back. If they bid $4,040 for Eagles and $3,990 for Buffalos, the round-trip cost is $180 per Eagle and $190 per Buffalo. Suddenly the coins are nearly even. These numbers are invented for the example; real quotes will differ.
The lesson: compare ask price minus bid price, not just the sticker. Our piece on premium over spot covers what goes into those spreads.
Premiums are easier to judge when you know where spot has been. Here's gold over the past year.
Gold price chart (USD per troy oz)
Over the past year, gold moved from $4,060.00 to $3,537.25 per troy ounce (-12.88%), with a high of $5,318.40 and a low of $3,530.45 (daily closes).
Selling later: recognition and liquidity
Both are US Mint bullion coins, and both are widely recognized by American dealers. The Gold Eagle has been around since 1986, two decades longer than the Buffalo, so it's especially familiar at local coin shops. That doesn't guarantee a better price, but it can mean fewer questions when you sell.
Both coins are counterfeited. Weigh any coin you buy outside a trusted dealer. A 1 oz Eagle should be close to 33.931 g, and a Buffalo close to 31.108 g. Mixing up those two numbers is a common way genuine coins get wrongly flagged as fakes, and fakes get passed as real.
If you're also considering a Krugerrand, which is 22K like the Eagle, our Krugerrand vs Gold Eagle comparison covers that matchup.
IRAs and taxes
For a precious-metals IRA, gold generally has to be .995 fine. The Buffalo, at .9999, clears that bar. The Gold Eagle is only 91.67% gold, but American Gold Eagles are specifically allowed by law. So both can generally go in an IRA held through an IRS-approved custodian. Details are in which gold coins qualify for an IRA; confirm the current rules with your custodian.
Outside an IRA, the IRS treats both coins as collectibles. Gains held more than a year face a maximum federal rate of 28%, and short-term gains are taxed as ordinary income. Keep receipts and check with a tax adviser.
Mistakes buyers make with these two coins
- Paying extra for "purer" gold. A .9999 coin doesn't give you more gold than a 22K one-ounce coin. If the Buffalo costs more that day, you're paying for purity as a feature, not for metal.
- Treating proofs as bullion. Both coins are also sold in proof versions for collectors. Proofs carry the same gold but much higher prices, and dealers often buy them back closer to bullion value. Know which one you're buying.
- Comparing a 1 oz price to a fractional price. A 1/10 oz Eagle at a tenth of the 1 oz price would be unusual. Always convert to price per ounce of gold.
- Forgetting shipping and payment fees. Some dealers charge more for card payments than for bank wires or checks. Add those costs before you compare.
- Cleaning or handling bare coins. Fingerprints and polish marks can make a buyer offer less. Keep coins in their capsules and hold them by the edges.
Which one fits you? Five scenarios
If you want the lowest cost per ounce, it's a coin flip that depends on the day. Get quotes on both and buy whichever has the smaller spread.
If you want to buy in small amounts, the Gold Eagle comes in 1/2, 1/4 and 1/10 oz sizes, making it easy to start small or sell a piece at a time. Fractional coins cost more per ounce, which our fractional gold coins guide explains.
If your coins will be handled often, say passed to family or shown around, the tougher 22K Eagle holds up better.
If you specifically want 24K purity, the Buffalo gives you that in a US Mint coin.
If you're unsure, owning some of each is perfectly reasonable. They hold the same gold and you won't regret either.
None of this is a recommendation to buy gold at all. That depends on your finances and goals. If you're comparing gold with older US coins, our guide to pre-1933 gold coins shows how classic gold stacks up.
Quick buying checklist
- Check the live gold price before you call or click.
- Get the ask price for both coins from at least two dealers.
- Ask each dealer what they pay to buy each coin back.
- Compare the spreads, not the sticker prices.
- Weigh coins bought privately against the official weights above.
- Store each coin in a capsule so the softer Buffalo stays mark-free.
Written by Editorial Team and checked against official sources under our editorial policy. Spotted an error? See our corrections policy.