Guide · Silver Coins & Junk Silver
Buying Junk Silver: Premiums, Bags and What to Avoid
When you buy junk silver, you pay the melt value of the silver plus a premium, so the number that matters is your total cost per troy ounce. Each $1 of face value in worn 90% coins holds about 0.715 ozt, so divide the price per $1 face by 0.715 to see what you're paying per ounce. Then compare that against other dealers and other forms of silver before you commit.
This guide covers what drives the premium, what each bag size really holds, and the mistakes that cost new buyers money. It's information, not a recommendation to buy.
What you're actually paying for
A junk silver price has two parts:
- Melt value. The silver content times the spot price. At today's price, $1 face of 90% coins holds about $29.37 of silver.
- Premium. Everything above melt: the dealer's costs, counting and handling, and whatever the market will bear for physical coins that week.
Premiums on junk silver aren't fixed. They rise when lots of people want physical silver at once and fall when demand cools. That means the "cheap" option one month can be the expensive one the next. Our explainer on premium over spot covers why retail metal always costs more than the spot price.
Today's spot prices for silver and gold are shown below. The silver figure is the starting point for any junk silver quote.
Worked example: turning a quote into price per ounce
Say silver is $40 an ounce and a dealer offers a $100 face bag of 90% coins at $3,150.
- Silver in the bag: 100 × 0.715 = 71.5 ozt.
- Melt value: 71.5 × $40 = $2,860.
- Premium: $3,150 − $2,860 = $290, or about 10% over melt.
- Cost per ounce: $3,150 ÷ 71.5 = about $44.06.
That last number is the one to compare. If another seller offers a $10 face roll at $318, that's $318 ÷ 7.15 = $44.48 per ounce. Close, and the smaller roll might suit you better if you don't want to spend $3,000 at once. Our junk silver calculator will give you the live melt for any face value so you can do this in seconds.
Bag sizes and what they hold
Junk silver is sold in face value units. Here is what each common lot contains, using the trade standard for worn coins:
| Lot | Silver content | Approximate weight | Typical buyer |
|---|---|---|---|
| $1 face | 0.715 ozt | 25 g | Trying it out, gifts |
| $10 face (one roll of quarters or halves) | 7.15 ozt | 250 g, about half a pound | Small, regular purchases |
| $100 face | 71.5 ozt | 2.5 kg, about 5.5 lb | Building a stack |
| $1,000 face ("full bag") | about 715 ozt | 25 kg, about 55 lb | Large buyers |
Smaller lots usually carry a higher premium per ounce because the dealer's handling cost is spread over less silver. Full bags often get the best per-ounce price but tie up a lot of money and are heavy. For more on each size, see our guide to junk silver bag sizes.
Myths and facts about buying junk silver
"Junk silver is always cheaper than bullion."
Not always. Sometimes 90% coins carry a lower premium than a one-ounce coin, and sometimes a higher one. Compare price per ounce each time. Our breakdown of junk silver vs Silver Eagles and bars walks through the other trade-offs.
"Dimes, quarters and halves are all the same."
In silver per dollar of face, yes. In price, not quite. Some dealers charge a little more for dimes because buyers like the small units, or a little less for halves. Ask for the price per denomination if it matters to you.
"Culls are a bad deal."
Not necessarily. Culls are coins that are bent, holed, heavily worn or damaged. They have no collector value and can lose a bit more silver to wear, so dealers often price them lower. If you only care about silver, a fair price on culls can be fine. Just know what you're getting.
"Anything labeled 'silver' is junk silver."
No. Silver-plated tokens, clad coins and silver-colored replicas show up in mixed lots. Junk silver means genuine pre-1965 US 90% coins, or 40% Kennedy halves when stated.
Dimes, quarters or halves: which mix to ask for
Because every denomination holds the same silver per dollar, the choice comes down to how you plan to use it.
- Dimes are the smallest pieces, at 0.07234 ozt each when new. If you want maximum flexibility to sell a little at a time, they're the most divisible option. The cost is counting: $100 face is 1,000 coins.
- Quarters sit in the middle. They're instantly recognizable and a $10 roll is a convenient unit of about seven ounces.
- Halves are the fastest to count and store, with 200 coins per $100 face. Walking Liberty and Franklin halves are common in junk lots.
Many buyers end up with a mix, which is fine. If one denomination is noticeably cheaper per ounce on a given day, that's often the simplest way to decide.
Plan for storage before the coins arrive. Plain coin tubes sized for each denomination keep rolls tidy and make counting at sale time easy.
What to look at before you pay
Here's the coin mix a typical 90% lot might contain, with the live melt value of each coin.
| Coin | Years | Metal content | Melt value | × face |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1916–1945 | 0.0723 oz silver | $2.97 | 29.7× | |
| 1946–1964 | 0.0723 oz silver | $2.97 | 29.7× | |
| 1932–1964 | 0.1808 oz silver | $7.44 | 29.7× | |
| 1948–1963 | 0.3617 oz silver | $14.87 | 29.7× |
Melt value = metal content × today’s spot price. It is not what a dealer pays (usually less) or a collector’s price (often more).
When the coins are in front of you, check:
- Dates. Every dime and quarter should be 1964 or earlier. Halves should be 1964 or earlier for 90%, or 1965 to 1970 for 40%.
- Edges. No copper stripe. A single clad quarter in a roll means less silver than you paid for.
- Count. 50 dimes to a $5 roll, 40 quarters or 20 halves to a $10 roll.
- Weight. A 90% Washington silver quarter weighs 6.25 g new, while a clad quarter weighs 5.67 g. A roll that weighs too little deserves a closer look.
Red flags that mean walk away
- A price well below melt from a stranger. Real junk silver doesn't sell for much less than its metal. A deal that looks too good usually is.
- Sealed rolls you can't open. Ask to inspect the ends or the coins. Honest sellers let you look.
- Pressure to buy "rare" coins at a big premium when you asked for junk silver. Collectible coins are a different market with different risks.
- Payment by wire or gift card to an unknown seller. Stick to methods with some protection, and to sellers with a real track record.
- Coins that look too new or too uniform. Counterfeits exist, especially of silver dollars. Our guide to spotting fake silver coins covers weight, size and detail checks.
Taxes and records
Coins and bullion count as collectibles for IRS purposes, and state sales tax on coins varies by state. Keep every receipt showing date, face value and price paid, because you'll need your cost basis when you sell. Confirm your own situation with a tax adviser.
Before-you-buy checklist
- Check the live silver price and work out melt per $1 face.
- Convert each quote into dollars per troy ounce.
- Decide on a lot size that fits your budget and storage.
- Inspect dates, edges, counts and weights.
- Buy from an established shop or dealer, and keep the receipt.
New to all this? Start with our beginner's guide to junk silver, then weigh the pros and cons in is junk silver a good investment.
Written by Editorial Team and checked against official sources under our editorial policy. Spotted an error? See our corrections policy.