Guide · Silver Coins & Junk Silver

Finding Silver in Pocket Change: Coin Roll Hunting Basics

Finding Silver in Pocket Change: Coin Roll Hunting Basics

Coin roll hunting means buying rolls of coins from a bank at face value, searching them for silver and other keepers, and returning the rest. The main targets are 90% silver dimes, quarters and halves dated 1964 or earlier, 40% silver Kennedy halves from 1965 to 1970 and silver war nickels from 1942 to 1945. You only ever risk face value, so the worst case is a few hours of sorting.

What are you actually looking for?

Silver was removed from dimes and quarters by the Coinage Act of 1965, and half dollars went to 40% silver until 1970. Old silver still turns up because people spend grandparents' coin jars without checking. Here's the cheat sheet.

DenominationKeepersHow to spot them
Dimes1964 and earlier (90% silver)Solid silver-colored edge, no copper stripe
Quarters1964 and earlier (90% silver)Solid silver edge; check the date
Half dollars1964 and earlier (90%), 1965–1970 Kennedys (40%)Read the date on every coin
Nickels1942–1945 war nickels (35% silver)Large P, D or S mint mark above Monticello's dome
CentsWheat cents (1909–1958), 95% copper cents before 1982Wheat ears on the back; date

The table below shows today's melt value for the silver coins you're most likely to find.

CoinYearsMetal contentMelt value× face
Roosevelt Dime (silver)1946–19640.0723 oz silver $2.9729.7×
Washington Quarter (silver)1932–19640.1808 oz silver $7.4429.7×
1964 Kennedy Half Dollar (90% silver)19640.3617 oz silver $14.8729.7×
Kennedy Half Dollar (40% silver)1965–19700.1479 oz silver $6.1612.3×
Jefferson War Nickel (35% silver)1942–19450.0563 oz silver $2.3546.9×

Melt value = metal content × today’s spot price. It is not what a dealer pays (usually less) or a collector’s price (often more).

War nickels are the sleeper find because they look like ordinary Jefferson nickels at a glance. Our guide to war nickel silver content explains the mint mark trick in detail. For halves, the Kennedy half dollar silver years guide sorts out 90%, 40% and clad.

How to coin roll hunt, step by step

  1. Pick a denomination. Most hunters start with half dollars, because a single find carries more silver and there are fewer coins per dollar to check.
  2. Get rolls from a bank. Ask at the teller window for rolls or a box. Policies vary: some banks need you to be a customer, some charge fees and some have little on hand. Our tips on where to get bank coin rolls help here.
  3. Set up a sorting space. A towel on a table, good light and a few small cups for keepers, maybes and returns.
  4. Check edges first. Stack dimes or quarters and look at the side. A solid silver-colored coin in a stack of copper stripes jumps right out.
  5. Read dates on halves and nickels. Edges help less here, so look at each date.
  6. Swap your finds for face value. Replace each keeper with an ordinary coin so the roll stays full, then re-roll.
  7. Record what you found. A simple notebook keeps track of how many rolls you searched and what turned up.

Not sure about a coin? Our guide on how to tell if a coin is silver covers the edge, weight and sound checks.

Tools that make searching faster

You don't need much gear, but a few cheap items save a lot of squinting.

  • A bright desk lamp. Dates on worn halves and nickels are hard to read in dim light.
  • A 5x to 10x magnifier. Handy for mint marks and for checking whether a nickel's mark sits above the dome.
  • A digital scale reading to 0.01 grams. It settles doubtful cases: 2.50 grams for a silver dime against 2.268 for clad, and 12.50 grams for a 90% half against 11.50 for a 40% one.
  • Paper coin wrappers in each size, so returns go back neatly.
  • Small labeled tubes or cups for keepers, so finds don't drift back into the return pile.

Many hunters also keep a short list of dates they want for a collection, so they can pull those as well as silver. That turns a box of halves into two hobbies at once.

What are the odds of finding silver?

Honestly, nobody can give you a reliable figure. Results depend on your area, your bank, the denomination and luck. Some boxes yield nothing. Others contain a dumped collection with a whole run of silver. Halves tend to be the most rewarding because many people never spend them, so they sit in drawers for decades and come back in bunches.

Think of it as a hobby with a small expected return, not as a paycheck. The upside is that you never lose money on the coins themselves.

Worked example: one box of halves

Say you search 10 rolls of halves, which is $100 face and 200 coins, and you find two 40% Kennedys and one 90% Franklin. Suppose silver is $40 an ounce, just for illustration.

  • Two 40% halves: 2 × 0.14792 = 0.29584 troy ounces.
  • One 90% half: 0.36169 troy ounces.
  • Total: 0.65753 ounces × $40 = about $26.30 in silver.
  • Cost: $1.50 face, because you swapped in three ordinary halves to keep the rolls whole.

That's a nice return on a pizza-and-sorting evening, though plenty of boxes produce less. Check today's figures on our 40% Kennedy half page.

Coin roll hunting etiquette

Banks don't have to sell you rolls, so a good relationship keeps the hobby open for everyone.

  • Call ahead before asking for large amounts.
  • Don't return searched rolls to the same branch they came from, and never dump loose, unsorted coins on a teller.
  • Return coins rolled properly in standard sizes: 50 dimes, 40 quarters, 20 halves, 40 nickels, 50 cents.
  • Use self-service coin counters where available, and check for fees first.
  • Be friendly and brief at busy times. Tellers remember the polite regulars.

Mistakes new hunters make

  • Treating every old-looking coin as silver. Darkness says nothing about metal.
  • Assuming every 1964-or-earlier coin is only worth melt. Check dates and mint marks before selling.
  • Cleaning finds. It doesn't add silver and can damage any collector value.
  • Melting cents or nickels. Federal rules prohibit melting 1-cent and 5-cent coins, though silver war nickels are exempt and saving coins is legal.

What to do with your finds

  1. Store silver keepers in a tube, sorted by denomination.
  2. Add them to your running total at 0.715 ounces per $1 face once you have a decent stack.
  3. Check any interesting date in a price guide before treating it as melt.
  4. Read our explainer on what junk silver is so you know how dealers will price the pile when you sell.

Written by Editorial Team and checked against official sources under our editorial policy. Spotted an error? See our corrections policy.

Frequently asked questions

Is coin roll hunting legal?
Yes. Buying coin rolls from a bank at face value, keeping coins you want and returning the rest is legal. Owning and saving pennies and nickels is legal too. What federal rules prohibit is melting or exporting 1-cent and 5-cent coins beyond certain exceptions, and silver war nickels are exempt.
Which coins are best for finding silver?
Half dollars are the favorite because many sit in drawers for years, and a single find holds a lot of silver: 0.36169 troy ounces in a 90% half and 0.14792 in a 40% half. Dimes and quarters still turn up, and edge checks make them quick to search.
Do banks charge for coin rolls?
It varies. Some banks give rolls free to customers, some charge a fee, some limit how many you can get and some don't stock half dollars at all. Ask your branch about its policy before you go, and be clear about the amount you want.
How can I tell a silver quarter from a clad one quickly?
Look at the edge. A 90% silver quarter, dated 1964 or earlier, has a solid silver-colored edge. A clad quarter from 1965 on shows a copper stripe. If you have a scale, a silver quarter weighs 6.25 grams, while a clad quarter weighs 5.67 grams.

More in Silver Coins & Junk Silver