Guide · Scrap Gold & Silver

Cash-for-Gold Shops vs Refiners vs Pawn Shops: Who Pays More?

Cash-for-Gold Shops vs Refiners vs Pawn Shops: Who Pays More?

For plain scrap gold, buyers closer to the refinery usually pay a bigger share of melt value, and storefront cash-for-gold shops and pawn shops usually pay less in exchange for speed and convenience. The gap between the best and worst offer on the same bag of jewelry can be hundreds of dollars. The only way to know is to work out your melt value first and ask every buyer for a number you can compare against it.

No law or industry standard sets what any of these buyers must pay, so treat the categories below as tendencies, not rules. A good local shop can beat a careless refiner.

Who buys scrap gold, and how does each one make money?

Every buyer earns a margin between what they pay you and what the refinery pays them. The more steps between you and the refinery, the more margins come out of your check.

Cash-for-gold storefronts and mall kiosks

These shops exist to buy gold, test it on the spot and hand you cash. They bundle what they buy and sell it on to a refiner. Their rent, staff and advertising come out of the spread, and some rely on customers who never check the gold price. Offers vary from fair to poor.

Pawn shops

A pawn shop looks at your piece two ways: can it be resold in the display case, or is it scrap? It may also offer a loan against the item instead of buying it. Pawn shops tend to price conservatively because they carry risk on loans and resale. Our guide to pawn shops versus coin shops covers the same trade-off for coins.

Jewelers and coin shops

Many jewelers and coin dealers buy scrap gold too. A jeweler may pay above scrap for a signed or resalable piece. Coin shops follow the spot price all day and often post their scrap buy rates, which makes comparison easier.

Refiners

A refiner melts the gold, assays it (measures exactly how much gold is in the melt) and pays on that result, less a refining fee. Because you skip middlemen, the payout share can be the highest. The catch: many refiners set minimum lot sizes, take time to assay, and some only deal with businesses. For a look at what happens inside, read how gold refining works and why buyers deduct.

Side-by-side comparison

BuyerSpeedTypical share of meltBest forWatch for
Cash-for-gold shopSame visitVaries widely, often on the low sideSmall lots, fast cashLumping karats, vague quotes
Pawn shopSame visitOften conservativeShort-term loans, resalable piecesLoan terms, low scrap offers
JewelerSame visit or a few daysVaries; may pay more for wearable piecesSigned or designer jewelryScrap price on good pieces
Coin shopSame visitOften posted and tied to spotMixed lots, coins plus jewelryMinimums, ID requirements
RefinerDays to weeksOften the highest, paid on assayLarger lots, dental goldMinimum lot size, fees, shipping risk
Mail-in buyerAbout a week or moreVaries widelyPeople with no local optionsLow first offers, return terms

Mail-in buyers sit somewhere between a shop and a refiner. They have their own risks, which we cover in how mail-in gold buyers work.

What does the gap look like in dollars?

Here's a worked example with round, illustrative numbers. The offers are made up to show the maths; they are not market rates.

Say you have 30 grams of 14K jewelry and 10 grams of 10K, and pure gold is $100 a gram for the example.

  • 14K: 30 g × 0.585 = 17.55 g of pure gold
  • 10K: 10 g × 0.417 = 4.17 g of pure gold
  • Total: 21.72 g of pure gold, worth $2,172 at the example price

Now three hypothetical offers come in:

BuyerOfferShare of melt
Mall kiosk$1,300About 60%
Local coin shop$1,800About 83%
Refiner (after fee)$1,950About 90%

Same gold, a $650 spread. That's why the melt figure matters more than the buyer's friendly manner. You can run your own numbers in the calculator below: pick each karat, enter the weight, and it shows the melt value at today's gold price.

Scrap gold calculator

Add each item (or each karat) with its weight. Remove stones and non-gold parts first.

Melt —
Melt —
Pure gold—
Melt value—
Estimated offer—
Gold spot$3,537.25

Melt = weight × purity × spot price per gram. Refiners and buyers deduct for assay, refining and profit, so offers are usually 70–90% of melt for karat jewelry.

The same tool lives on our scrap gold calculator page if you want to bookmark it before you shop around.

Tactics that cost sellers money

Most buyers are honest, but a few habits show up often enough to name. Our full list is in gold buyer tricks to watch for.

  • Lumping karats. Weighing 10K, 14K and 18K together and paying the 10K rate on everything.
  • Quoting in pennyweight without saying so. A per-dwt price sounds bigger than a per-gram one. One dwt is 1.5552 grams.
  • A scale you can't see. Ask for the weight to be shown to you in grams, and bring your own reading from home.
  • "Today only" pressure. Gold trades nearly 24 hours a day on weekdays. A fair offer will still be roughly fair tomorrow.
  • A lump-sum number. If the buyer won't break the total down by karat and weight, you can't check it.

Which buyer fits your situation?

Match the buyer to the pile on your table:

  • A single broken chain or one earring: a local coin shop or jeweler is usually simplest. The amount is too small for most refiners.
  • A drawer of mixed old jewelry: get two or three local quotes, then compare against a refiner or reputable mail-in buyer if the lot is large.
  • Signed or designer pieces: try a jeweler or estate buyer first. Scrap value is the floor, not the ceiling.
  • You need cash for a short time and want the item back: a pawn loan may fit, but read the interest and redemption terms closely.

Coins are a different matter. Gold coins can carry collector value above melt, so read our step-by-step guide to selling scrap gold for jewelry and keep coins separate.

Before you walk in: a quick checklist

  1. Sort pieces by karat stamp (10K, 14K, 18K, 417, 585, 750).
  2. Weigh each group in grams on a kitchen or jewelry scale.
  3. Check today's live gold price and work out melt for each group.
  4. Ask each buyer for an offer by karat and weight, not one lump sum.
  5. Divide each offer by your melt figure to get a percentage.
  6. Take the best fair offer, and get a receipt that lists weights and karats.

Bring a photo ID, since many buyers are required by state or local rules to record seller details. Requirements differ by place, so check with the buyer before you go.

Written by Editorial Team and checked against official sources under our editorial policy. Spotted an error? See our corrections policy.

Frequently asked questions

Do cash-for-gold shops pay less than refiners?
Often, but not always. Storefront buyers carry rent, staff and testing costs and then sell to a refiner, so their margin tends to be larger. A refiner pays on an assay, less fees, but may need a minimum lot. Compare actual offers as a percentage of your melt value before deciding.
Can I sell gold jewelry directly to a refiner?
Some refiners accept lots from the public and some deal only with businesses. Those that do may set minimum weights, charge assay and refining fees, and take days to pay. Call ahead, ask for the fee schedule in writing, and confirm how they handle small lots before you ship or visit.
Why do two shops give such different offers for the same gold?
Each buyer sets its own margin based on costs, competition and how much it expects you to know. Some also lump karats together or quote per pennyweight. Ask both shops for an offer broken down by karat and grams, then compare each against the same melt value.
Should I take a pawn loan instead of selling my gold?
A pawn loan lets you keep ownership and redeem the item later, which suits a short cash need for jewelry you want back. Loans carry interest and fees, and you lose the item if you don't repay. Read the terms and your state's pawn rules before agreeing.

More in Scrap Gold & Silver