Guide · Selling & Buying Coins

Do You Pay Taxes When You Sell Coins?

Do You Pay Taxes When You Sell Coins?

Yes, in most cases. The IRS treats coins and bullion as collectibles, so if you sell coins for more than you paid, the profit is a taxable capital gain. Coins held more than one year are taxed at a maximum federal rate of 28%, and coins held one year or less are taxed at your ordinary income rate.

If you sell for less than you paid, there's no gain to tax. The hard part for most people isn't the rate. It's proving what they paid.

What counts as a gain on coins?

Your gain is the sale price minus your cost basis. Basis is usually what you paid for the coins, and many people also count the dealer premium and any fees on the purchase as part of that cost. Confirm with a tax adviser what you're allowed to include.

Notice what's missing from that formula: face value. A 1964 quarter that you bought for $8 has a basis of $8, not 25 cents. And a coin you pulled from pocket change at face value has a basis of its face value, so nearly everything above that is gain if you sell it for its silver.

  • Sale price: what the buyer actually paid you, after any fees taken out.
  • Basis: what you paid, backed by a receipt, invoice or bank record.
  • Holding period: the time between the day you bought and the day you sold.

The collectibles rate, explained without jargon

Stocks and many other assets held long-term get their own lower capital gains rates. Coins don't follow that schedule. The IRS lumps coins, bullion, art and similar items together as collectibles, and long-term gains on them face a maximum federal rate of 28%.

That word "maximum" matters. It's a ceiling, not a flat charge on everyone. Depending on your total income, your actual rate on a collectibles gain may be lower. Your tax software or tax adviser works that out from your full return.

How long you held the coinsHow the gain is taxed (federal)
One year or lessShort-term: at your ordinary income tax rate
More than one yearLong-term collectible: maximum rate of 28%
Sold at a lossNo gain to tax; ask an adviser how the loss is treated

State income tax is a separate question. States handle it in their own ways, so check your state's rules or ask a local preparer.

Worked example: a roll of Morgans and a few gold coins

Here's an illustrative case with round numbers. Dana bought 10 Morgan silver dollars from a coin shop for $300 in total and kept the receipt. Three years later she sells all ten to a dealer for $500.

  1. Sale price: $500
  2. Basis: $300
  3. Gain: $500 minus $300 = $200
  4. Held more than one year, so it's a long-term collectible gain.
  5. Highest possible federal tax on that gain: 28% of $200 = $56.

If Dana had sold after eight months instead, the same $200 gain would be short-term and taxed at whatever her ordinary income rate is. For someone in a high bracket, that can cost more than the long-term ceiling.

Now say she also sells two old gold coins she can't find a receipt for. Without proof of basis, an adviser may tell her to treat a much larger share of the sale price as gain. That's the expensive mistake, and it's avoidable.

To see what your own coins are worth as metal before you sell, the calculator below uses today's spot prices.

Coin melt value calculator

Pick each coin and how many you have. Values update with the live spot price.

Melt $31.80
Melt $29.74
Melt $29.74
Total melt value—
Total face value—
Pure silver—
Pure gold—

Do coin dealers report your sale to the IRS?

Sometimes. Dealers may have to report certain sales to the IRS depending on what you sell and how much of it. The rules are specific to the product and quantity, so ask the dealer up front whether your sale triggers a report and what information they'll need from you.

Either way, the reporting question doesn't change your obligation. A sale that isn't reported by the dealer is still a sale you're expected to report yourself if you made a gain. Keep the dealer's receipt or invoice for every sale, the same way you keep purchase receipts.

Our guide on how coin dealers price coins explains the buy and sell spread you'll see on that receipt.

Situations that trip people up

Junk silver from pocket change

Someone who pulled silver dimes out of change paid face value. Selling a pile of them for silver means the basis is tiny and most of the sale is gain. Small amounts, but they add up over years of coin roll hunting.

Coins bought over many years

If you bought silver Eagles a few at a time, each purchase has its own date and price. Selling "some" of them means you need to know which ones you sold. A simple spreadsheet with date, quantity, price and seller saves headaches.

Inherited or gifted coins

Inherited and gifted coins have their own basis rules, and they differ from coins you bought yourself. Ask a tax adviser how to figure basis for yours, and read our checklist for an inherited coin collection before selling anything.

Sales tax when buying

Sales tax is a different tax, paid when you buy. State sales tax on bullion and coins varies by state, and some states exempt certain purchases. It isn't part of your income tax on a sale, though it may affect what you paid.

How to keep records that actually help

The best tax move with coins is boring: keep paperwork. You'll want it whether you sell next month or your heirs sell in thirty years.

  • Save every purchase invoice, including online order confirmations and shipping costs.
  • Note the date, coin, quantity, price per coin and seller.
  • Keep sale receipts from dealers, auction houses and private buyers.
  • Write down how you valued anything you didn't buy, like coins found in change.
  • Store copies in two places: a paper folder and a scan or photo in cloud storage.

For bullion bars and rounds, the same collectibles treatment applies. Our guide to taxes on gold and silver bullion covers buying, holding and selling bars in more detail.

Before you sell: a quick tax checklist

Run through this before you walk into a shop or list coins online. It takes ten minutes and can save a real argument with your tax preparer later.

  1. Find your purchase records and total your basis for the coins you're selling.
  2. Check the purchase dates. Coins just under a year old may be worth holding a little longer.
  3. Look up the metal value on our coin melt value calculator so you know whether an offer is fair.
  4. Ask the buyer whether the sale will be reported and get a written receipt.
  5. Read our main guide on how to sell old coins for fair value to pick the right buyer.
  6. Talk to a tax adviser if the sale is large, the coins were inherited or your records are patchy.

This guide is general information, not tax advice. Tax rules change, so confirm the details for your situation with a tax adviser or the IRS.

Written by Editorial Team and checked against official sources under our editorial policy. Spotted an error? See our corrections policy.

Frequently asked questions

Do I pay tax if I sell coins for less than I paid?
No gain means no tax on the sale. If your sale price is below your cost basis, you have a loss rather than a gain. Whether and how you can use that loss on your return depends on your situation, so ask a tax adviser before you count on it.
What is the tax rate on selling gold and silver coins?
The IRS treats coins as collectibles. Long-term gains on coins held more than one year face a maximum federal rate of 28%. Coins held one year or less are taxed at your ordinary income rate. State income tax may also apply, so confirm your total picture with a tax adviser.
What if I don't have receipts for my coins?
Try to rebuild your records from bank statements, credit card statements, old emails and online order histories. Write down whatever you can prove. Without proof of basis you may end up treating more of the sale as gain, so a tax adviser's help is worth it here.
Do I owe tax on coins I found in pocket change?
If you sell them for more than face value, the difference is generally a gain, because your cost was the face value you paid. A few silver dimes sold to a dealer is a small gain, but it still counts. Ask a tax adviser how to report it.

More in Selling & Buying Coins