Guide · Pennies & Nickels

Buffalo Nickel Value: Metal Worth and What Collectors Pay More For

Buffalo Nickel Value: Metal Worth and What Collectors Pay More For

A Buffalo nickel (1913 to 1938) contains 5 grams of 75% copper and 25% nickel, worth about $0.0669 in metal at today's prices. A worn coin with no readable date usually sells for a small amount over face value, while a clear date, strong detail or a scarce date and mint mark can push the value well past melt. Condition is the biggest single factor.

Buffalo nickels contain no silver. The 35% silver nickels are the 1942 to 1945 Jefferson war nickels, not Buffalos.

Buffalo nickel specs

Also called the Indian Head nickel, the coin shows a Native American profile on the front and an American bison standing on a mound on the back.

  • Years: 1913 to 1938
  • Weight: 5.00 grams
  • Composition: 75% copper, 25% nickel
  • Silver: none

Our Buffalo nickel melt value page tracks the metal price daily, and the card below shows the same live figure with full specs.

Where does your Buffalo nickel fit?

Sort your coins into one of these four groups. It's the fastest way to know if you're holding pocket change or something to show a dealer.

What you seeTypical value rangeWhat to do
No date visible, heavy wearAround melt to a little over faceKeep as a curiosity, sell in bulk, or use for crafts
Readable date, common year, wornModest premium over meltGroup by date and mint mark, check a price guide
Full date, horn and feathers still sharpCan be well above meltStore carefully, compare against a current price guide
Scarce date or mint mark, variety or errorPotentially a strong premiumGet a reputable dealer or grading service opinion

We don't quote dollar amounts for specific dates, because prices change and depend heavily on grade. A current price guide or a dealer will give you real numbers.

Why so many Buffalo nickels have no date

The date sits on a raised spot on the front, at the base of the portrait, with nothing around it to protect it. After decades in pockets and cash drawers, it was one of the first details to wear flat. That's why coffee cans of old nickels are full of "dateless" Buffalos.

Dateless coins are common, so they carry little premium. You may see products sold to bring back a worn date with a chemical. They can reveal the year, but collectors and graders treat those coins as altered, and they usually sell for less than an untouched coin with a full date. If you're trying to sell a dateless coin, leave it alone.

What makes a Buffalo nickel worth more?

Condition

Look at the buffalo's horn, the tip of the tail and the feathers in the portrait's hair. On well-preserved coins these are crisp. On worn ones they blend into the background. The basics of coin grading show how dealers turn those details into a grade.

Date and mint mark

Buffalo nickels were struck at Philadelphia, Denver and San Francisco. Look on the back, below the bison, for a small D or S; Philadelphia coins have no mint mark. Some date and mint combinations were made in smaller numbers or survive less often, and those carry premiums. Our mint mark guide helps if you're unsure what you're looking at.

Varieties and errors

Specialists recognize design changes, doubled dies, overdates and other quirks. Most worn coins from a jar won't be one of them, but anything that looks odd under a magnifier is worth a second opinion. See what to look for in error coins.

Original surfaces

Cleaned, polished or scratched coins lose collector appeal fast. Original toning is preferred over shiny.

Worked example: a jar of 60 Buffalo nickels

Say you inherit a jar with 60 Buffalo nickels. You sort them and find 35 with no date, 22 with worn but readable common dates, and 3 with sharp detail.

Metal floor. With round example prices of $4.50 a pound for copper and $7 a pound for nickel, each coin holds about 3.75 g of copper (roughly 3.7 cents) and 1.25 g of nickel (roughly 1.9 cents). That's about 5.6 cents of metal per coin, or about $3.40 for all 60. Today's real figure per coin is $0.0669.

Collector layer. The 35 dateless coins are close to that floor. The 22 dated coins might fetch a modest premium each. The 3 sharp coins are the ones to price individually with a current guide. In many inherited lots, a handful of coins account for most of the value.

Want to see how the Buffalo stacks up against other nickels? The live table below lists all the nickel types we track.

CoinYearsMetal contentMelt value× face
Shield Nickel1866–18835 g · 75% copper $0.06691.3×
Liberty Head “V” Nickel1883–19125 g · 75% copper $0.06691.3×
Buffalo Nickel1913–19385 g · 75% copper $0.06691.3×
Jefferson Nickel1938–present (except 1942–1945 silver issues)5 g · 75% copper $0.06691.3×
Jefferson War Nickel (35% silver)1942–19450.0563 oz silver $2.3546.9×

Melt value = metal content × today’s spot price. It is not what a dealer pays (usually less) or a collector’s price (often more).

Every nickel except the war years uses the same 5-gram copper-nickel alloy, so a Buffalo, a Liberty V and a modern Jefferson share the same melt value. Our article on what nickels are made of explains why.

Can you melt Buffalo nickels for the metal?

No. Under 31 CFR Part 82, melting or exporting US 5-cent coins is prohibited except in limited cases, and only the 1942 to 1945 silver war nickels are exempt. Buffalo nickels are not. Penalties reach a $10,000 fine and/or five years in prison. Selling them as coins to collectors is fine. The pillar on saving copper pennies and nickels covers the rule in more depth.

Mistakes that cost Buffalo nickel owners money

  • Cleaning coins to make them shine.
  • Restoring dates with acid before showing them to a buyer.
  • Selling a whole jar at one price without pulling out the sharp coins.
  • Assuming Buffalo nickels are silver and expecting silver prices.
  • Buying "rare" Buffalos online without checking authenticity.

Your Buffalo nickel checklist

  1. Separate dateless coins from dated ones.
  2. For dated coins, note the year and look under the bison for a D or S.
  3. Check the horn, tail and feathers for sharpness.
  4. Look up promising coins in a current price guide.
  5. Take the best ones to a reputable dealer, and read how to sell old coins before you accept an offer.

Written by Editorial Team and checked against official sources under our editorial policy. Spotted an error? See our corrections policy.

Frequently asked questions

Are Buffalo nickels silver?
No. Buffalo nickels from 1913 to 1938 are 75% copper and 25% nickel and weigh 5 grams, with no silver at all. The only US nickels with silver are the 1942 to 1945 Jefferson war nickels, which are 35% silver.
What is a Buffalo nickel with no date worth?
Usually not much more than its metal value or a little over face, because dateless Buffalo nickels are very common. The date wore off on most circulated coins. Chemically restoring the date tends to lower collector value, so it's best to sell dateless coins as they are.
How do I find the mint mark on a Buffalo nickel?
Turn the coin over and look below the buffalo, near the words FIVE CENTS at the bottom. A small D means Denver and an S means San Francisco. No letter means Philadelphia. A magnifier helps on worn coins.
Where can I sell Buffalo nickels?
Local coin shops, coin shows and online marketplaces all buy them. Dealers often buy worn and dateless coins in bulk. Price better coins individually using a current price guide, and get a second opinion on anything that may be scarce before you sell.

More in Pennies & Nickels