Guide · Selling & Buying Coins

Error Coins: What to Look For

Error Coins: What to Look For

Error coins are coins the Mint made incorrectly: struck off-center, struck twice, struck with a doubled die, or struck on the wrong metal blank. The main ones to look for are doubled dies, off-center strikes, wrong planchets (like a 1943 copper cent), clipped planchets and missing or broken design elements. Most "errors" people find turn out to be damage after the coin left the Mint, so real ones need careful checking and often authentication.

Error or damage? The first question to ask

An error happens during minting. Damage happens afterward, in a pocket, a washing machine, a parking lot or a vise. Collectors pay for genuine errors. They don't pay for damage, no matter how strange it looks.

What you seeLikely a Mint error ifLikely damage if
Doubled letters or dateBoth images are rounded and raised, with clear separationThe extra image is flat, shelf-like or looks pushed sideways
Odd colorWeight and magnet test match a different metalColor comes from heat, chemicals or plating
Missing chunk of rimCurved clip with the rim fading out near the gapSharp, jagged cut or the design is squashed nearby
Coin too thin or too thickWeight still sits within a plausible rangeCoin was ground, hammered or acid-treated
Design off to one sideBlank area is smooth and the rim is missing on that sideRim exists all the way around; the design is just worn

The main types of error coins

Doubled die

The die that strikes the coin was itself made with a doubled image, so every coin it struck shows the same doubling. Look for doubling in the date, the motto and the lettering. Genuine doubled dies show two distinct, rounded raised images. A loupe or a 10x magnifier helps a lot.

Don't confuse this with machine doubling, also called strike doubling. That's caused by a loose die bouncing during the strike and leaves a flat, stair-step look. It's very common and adds little or nothing to value.

Off-center strike

The blank wasn't seated properly, so the design landed partly off the coin. Part of the coin shows a plain, smooth area. Collectors usually prefer coins where the full date is still visible, so they can identify the year.

Wrong planchet (wrong metal)

A planchet is the blank metal disk the coin is struck on. Occasionally a blank meant for one coin, or one left over from an earlier year, gets struck with a different design. The most famous US example is the 1943 bronze cent. Regular 1943 cents were zinc-coated steel to save copper for World War II, so a copper-colored 1943 cent is a famous rare error. Most are fakes, often copper-plated steel cents or altered dates.

Clipped planchet

The blank was punched from a strip of metal that overlapped a hole from a previous punch, leaving a curved bite out of the edge. Genuine clips have a curved edge, and the rim usually weakens or fades near the clip.

Struck-through and missing elements

Grease, debris or other material sat on the die during the strike, so part of the design came out weak or missing. Small examples are common and modest. Dramatic ones attract more interest.

Broadstrikes and multiple strikes

A coin struck without the collar that shapes its edge spreads out wider and flatter. A coin struck twice shows overlapping designs. Both are clear, visible errors, though values depend on how dramatic the error is and on the coin.

Worked example: testing a "1943 copper penny"

Say a reader named Alicia finds a copper-colored 1943 cent in an old jar. Before getting excited, she can run two free tests with a magnet and a kitchen scale that reads to hundredths of a gram.

  1. Magnet test. A regular 1943 steel cent sticks to a magnet. If hers sticks, it's a steel cent that was plated or colored, not a rare error.
  2. Weight test. A steel cent weighs 2.70 grams. Bronze cents of that era weigh 3.11 grams. A non-magnetic coin weighing close to 3.11 grams passes this step.
  3. Date check. Under magnification, she checks that the last digit of the date hasn't been altered from another number, a known trick with fakes.
  4. Authentication. If it passes all three, it goes to a reputable third-party grading service before anyone puts a price on it.

The card below shows the metal value of an ordinary 1943 steel cent, which is what nearly all of them are.

Our full guide to the 1943 steel penny covers its metal and collector value in more depth, and you can see its specs on the 1943 steel cent page.

The same weight logic works on silver. A 1965 quarter should be clad, weighing 5.67 grams with a copper stripe on the edge. One that weighs 6.25 grams and shows a solid silver edge could be a wrong-planchet error worth authenticating.

Common myths about error coins

  • "Every odd-looking coin is an error." Most are post-Mint damage or wear.
  • "A 1982 penny that weighs differently is an error." No. Both copper and zinc cents were made that year. See our guide to 1982 pennies.
  • "Online listings show what errors are worth." Asking prices are hopes. Completed sales and dealer offers are the reality.
  • "Cleaning will show the error better." Cleaning damages the surface and lowers value. Leave it as found.

What error coins are worth

There's no single answer, and anyone quoting a fixed price without seeing your coin is guessing. Value depends on the type of error, how dramatic it is, the coin and date, the condition and how many similar pieces are known. Minor errors may bring a small premium. Major, dramatic errors on popular coins can bring far more.

For anything that looks significant, authentication matters as much as the error itself. Our guide on whether it's worth getting coins graded walks through cost versus benefit. And errors are just one reason a coin can beat melt, so run through our list of coins to check before selling for melt too.

Your error-hunting checklist

  1. Get a 10x loupe, a magnet and a scale that reads to 0.01 g.
  2. Check doubling on dates, mottos and lettering, and judge whether it's rounded or flat.
  3. Weigh anything with an odd color and compare with official specs.
  4. Look at rims for curved clips and for coins struck without a collar.
  5. Rule out damage before assuming an error.
  6. Store suspected errors in a safe, inert holder and don't clean them.
  7. Get a reputable opinion or authentication before selling, then follow our guide to selling old coins.

Written by Editorial Team and checked against official sources under our editorial policy. Spotted an error? See our corrections policy.

Frequently asked questions

How can I tell if my coin is a real error?
Compare it with a normal coin of the same type, check weight and magnetism against official specs, and look for signs of damage like flat, pushed metal or tool marks. Genuine errors happen during striking and have consistent features. For anything promising, get an opinion from a reputable dealer or grading service.
Is machine doubling worth anything?
Usually very little. Machine doubling, also called strike doubling, comes from a loose die bouncing during striking and leaves flat, shelf-like doubling. It's common. A true doubled die shows rounded, raised doubled images and is the type collectors pay premiums for.
Where can I get an error coin authenticated?
Major third-party grading services authenticate and attribute error coins and seal them in labeled holders. Many reputable coin dealers can also give you an initial opinion. Check fees and turnaround times with the service first, and only submit coins that look likely to be genuine.

More in Selling & Buying Coins