Guide · Silver Coins & Junk Silver

War Nickels: How to Spot 35% Silver Nickels from 1942–1945

War Nickels: How to Spot 35% Silver Nickels from 1942–1945

War nickels are Jefferson nickels struck from 1942 to 1945 in an alloy of 56% copper, 35% silver and 9% manganese. Each one holds 0.05626 troy ounces of silver, worth about $2.35 at today's price. You can spot them by the large P, D or S mint mark above the dome of Monticello on the back.

Every other Jefferson nickel is the usual 75% copper, 25% nickel alloy and contains no silver.

How to spot a war nickel in four steps

  1. Find the date. It must read 1942, 1943, 1944 or 1945. Anything outside those years is not a war nickel.
  2. Turn the coin over. Look at Monticello, the building on the back.
  3. Look above the dome. War nickels carry a large mint mark letter, P, D or S, sitting right over the dome. It's noticeably bigger than mint marks on other nickels.
  4. Check for the P. A P on a nickel is a dead giveaway. The war years were the only time Philadelphia put a P on a nickel before 1980.

If a 1942 to 1945 nickel has no large letter above the dome, treat it as an ordinary copper-nickel coin. The big mint mark is your test. Our guide to reading mint marks on US coins covers where to look on other denominations.

The card below shows the war nickel's specs and its live melt value, so you can see what one is worth right now.

War nickel specifications

SpecWar nickel (1942–1945)Regular Jefferson nickel
Weight5.00 g5.00 g
Composition56% copper, 35% silver, 9% manganese75% copper, 25% nickel
Silver content0.05626 oztNone
Mint markLarge P, D or S above Monticello's domeNot above the dome
Melting rulesExempt from the federal melting banMelting for metal is prohibited

Both coins weigh the same, so a scale won't tell them apart. The date and mint mark will. For more on the regular alloy, see what nickels are made of.

How much silver is in war nickels?

One war nickel holds 0.05626 troy ounces of pure silver. That adds up quickly:

QuantityFace valueSilver
1 nickel$0.050.05626 ozt
20 nickels$1.001.1252 ozt
1 roll (40 nickels)$2.002.2504 ozt
About 18 nickelsabout $0.90about 1.01 ozt

Here's a surprise: per dollar of face value, war nickels hold more silver than 90% coins. Twenty war nickels ($1 face) contain about 1.1252 ozt, while $1 face of 90% dimes, quarters or halves holds 0.7234 ozt when new. Nickels are cheap relative to their weight, so even a 35% alloy packs a lot of silver per dollar of face.

Worked example

Say Teresa finds a roll of 40 war nickels in her late uncle's dresser. That's $2 face and 2.2504 ozt of silver. If silver were $40 an ounce, the melt would be about $90. A dealer paying 90% of melt would offer about $81. The same 40 coins at a bank would be worth $2.

Are war nickels worth more than melt?

Most circulated war nickels sell for around their silver value, because worn examples of common dates are easy to find. A few things can lift one above melt:

  • Exceptional condition. Sharp steps on Monticello and original luster appeal to collectors.
  • Certain date and mint combinations. Some were struck in smaller numbers than others.
  • Errors and varieties. Minting mistakes attract specialists who pay for the oddity, not the silver.

We don't quote specific collector prices here because they depend on grade and change over time. Check a current price guide or ask a reputable dealer. Our Jefferson nickel value guide covers what to look for across the whole series, wartime and otherwise.

Here's how a war nickel compares with ordinary nickels in metal value today. The gap is almost entirely the silver.

CoinYearsMetal contentMelt value× face
Jefferson War Nickel (35% silver)1942–19450.0563 oz silver $2.3546.9×
Jefferson Nickel1938–present (except 1942–1945 silver issues)5 g · 75% copper $0.06691.3×
Buffalo Nickel1913–19385 g · 75% copper $0.06691.3×

Melt value = metal content × today’s spot price. It is not what a dealer pays (usually less) or a collector’s price (often more).

Yes. Federal rules under 31 CFR Part 82 say no one may export, melt or treat US 1-cent or 5-cent coins, with limited exceptions. The 1942–1945 silver war nickels are specifically exempt. Ordinary nickels and pennies are covered, and the penalty for breaking the rule is a fine of up to $10,000, imprisonment of up to five years, or both.

In practice, almost nobody needs to melt war nickels. Dealers buy them as coins, priced on silver content. Owning, saving and selling regular nickels and pennies as coins is legal too. The details are in our guide on whether it's illegal to melt pennies and nickels. If you're unsure how the rules apply to your situation, check the official text.

Common misreads when sorting nickels

  • Counting every 1942 nickel as silver. The date range is necessary but not enough. Only coins with the large letter above the dome are the silver alloy.
  • Mistaking a worn dome for a mint mark. On heavily worn coins, the area above Monticello can be smooth or scratched. Use a magnifier and good light; a genuine war nickel mark is a clear, large letter.
  • Using a magnet or scale. Neither sorts them. Both types weigh 5.00 g, so the scale reads the same, and the date and mint mark are a far more reliable test than a magnet.
  • Assuming dark means fake. Old nickels of any kind can darken with age. Toning sits on the surface and doesn't change the silver inside.

A sorting scenario

Say you have a coffee can with 600 nickels. Pull every coin dated 1942 to 1945 first; that might leave a few dozen. Flip those and check above the dome. If 25 carry the big P, D or S, you have 25 × 0.05626 = about 1.41 ozt of silver. The rest go back into circulation at five cents each.

Where war nickels turn up

Because they look like any other nickel from a few feet away, war nickels are easy to overlook, and plenty sat unnoticed in jars for decades. You'll find them in:

  • Old coin jars and piggy banks, often mixed with wheat pennies.
  • Estate lots and inherited collections.
  • Occasionally, bank rolls of nickels. Roll hunters still pull the odd one. Our guide to finding silver in pocket change explains how to search rolls.

Sorting goes fast once you know the trick. Flip each 1942–1945 nickel and look for the big letter over the dome. The coins with it go in the silver pile.

Selling war nickels

Many coin shops buy war nickels alongside 90% junk silver, though they're a separate product with their own price. Ask for a quote per coin or per roll, and compare it against the live melt. War nickels can also be priced as a multiple of face value, just like other junk silver; our guide to junk silver explains how that works.

A few practical tips:

  • Keep war nickels separate from 90% coins so the quote is clear.
  • Count them in rolls of 40 ($2 face).
  • Set aside any with sharp details or obvious errors before selling the rest at melt.
  • Don't clean them. Darkened old nickels are common and cleaning adds nothing.

War nickel quick checklist

  • Date 1942, 1943, 1944 or 1945.
  • Large P, D or S above Monticello's dome.
  • 0.05626 ozt of silver each; 2.2504 ozt per 40-coin roll.
  • Exempt from the federal melting ban, unlike other nickels.
  • Check the live war nickel melt value before you sell.

Written by Editorial Team and checked against official sources under our editorial policy. Spotted an error? See our corrections policy.

Frequently asked questions

What years are war nickels silver?
War nickels were struck from 1942 to 1945 in an alloy of 56% copper, 35% silver and 9% manganese. Only nickels from those years with the large P, D or S mint mark above Monticello's dome are silver. All other Jefferson nickels are copper-nickel.
How much is a war nickel worth?
Most circulated war nickels are worth about their melt value of $2.35 at today's silver price, since each holds 0.05626 troy ounces of silver. Coins in exceptional condition, scarce date and mint combinations, or errors can be worth more to collectors.
Why does a war nickel have a P on it?
The large P shows it was struck in Philadelphia. During the war years, the Mint placed a large mint mark above Monticello's dome, and it was the only time a P appeared on a nickel before 1980. That big letter is the easiest way to spot the silver coins.
Do war nickels weigh more than regular nickels?
No. Both war nickels and regular Jefferson nickels weigh 5.00 grams, so a scale can't separate them. Use the date and the large mint mark above Monticello's dome instead. The difference is in the alloy, not the weight.

More in Silver Coins & Junk Silver