Guide · Bullion Investing

Precious Metals IRA Basics: Rules, Custodians, Storage and Fees

Precious Metals IRA Basics: Rules, Custodians, Storage and Fees

A precious metals IRA is a self-directed retirement account that holds physical bullion instead of stocks or funds. It has to be run by an IRS-approved custodian, and the metal must meet purity rules: gold generally .995 fine (American Gold Eagles are specifically allowed), silver .999 fine. Collectible coins are not allowed.

That's the whole idea in three sentences. The details below cover what qualifies, who holds the metal, what it costs and where people get burned.

How does a precious metals IRA actually work?

You don't buy coins and then tuck them into your IRA. The account comes first, and the custodian buys and holds the metal on the account's behalf. Here's the usual sequence.

  1. Open a self-directed IRA with a custodian that handles physical metals. Most ordinary brokerage IRAs can't hold bars or coins.
  2. Fund it with a contribution, a transfer from another IRA or a rollover from a workplace plan. Contribution limits and rollover rules come from the IRS, so confirm them with the custodian and the official IRS pages before moving money.
  3. Pick a dealer and the products. You choose what to buy; the custodian checks that it's eligible and pays the dealer from the account.
  4. The metal goes into storage under the custodian's arrangement, not to your house.
  5. Later, you take distributions as cash (the custodian sells metal) or, in some cases, as the metal itself. Ask how in-kind distributions are valued and taxed before you rely on that option.

The paperwork matters more than with a normal coin purchase. Every step runs through the custodian, and doing it out of order can create a tax problem instead of a retirement asset.

Which metals and products qualify?

Two tests decide most cases: purity and whether the item is a collectible. Here's how common bullion stacks up using published fineness.

ProductFinenessGenerally eligible?
American Silver Eagle.999 silverYes, meets the silver standard
Canadian Silver Maple Leaf.9999 silverYes
American Gold Eagle22K (91.67%)Yes, specifically allowed
American Gold Buffalo, Gold Maple Leaf.9999 goldYes
South African Krugerrand22KGenerally no, below .995 and no carve-out
Junk silver (pre-1965 dimes, quarters, halves)90% silverNo, below .999
Morgan and Peace dollars, pre-1933 gold90%No, below standard and treated as collectibles
Platinum and Palladium Eagles.9995Ask your custodian for its current list

The live table below shows today's melt value for the main bullion coins, which is a good reminder that inside an IRA you're paying for metal content, not rarity.

CoinYearsMetal contentMelt value× face
American Silver Eagle (1 oz)1986–present0.9990 oz silver $41.0341.0×
American Gold Eagle (1 oz)1986–present1.0000 oz gold $3,538.6270.8×
American Gold Eagle (1/2 oz)1986–present0.5000 oz gold $1,769.3670.8×
American Gold Eagle (1/4 oz)1986–present0.2500 oz gold $884.6888.5×
American Gold Eagle (1/10 oz)1986–present0.1000 oz gold $353.8570.8×
American Gold Buffalo (1 oz)2006–present1.0000 oz gold $3,537.4170.7×
American Platinum Eagle (1 oz)1997–present1.0000 oz platinum $1,301.1913.0×
American Palladium Eagle (1 oz)2017–present1.0000 oz palladium $894.8835.8×
Canadian Silver Maple Leaf (1 oz)1988–present1.0001 oz silver $41.08—
Canadian Gold Maple Leaf (1 oz)1979–present1.0001 oz gold $3,537.64—
South African Krugerrand (1 oz)1967–present1.0000 oz gold $3,537.19—
British Silver Britannia (1 oz)2013–present1.0024 oz silver $41.17—

Melt value = metal content × today’s spot price. It is not what a dealer pays (usually less) or a collector’s price (often more).

Platinum and Palladium Eagles meet a high purity standard, but custodian lists differ, so check before buying; our guide to platinum and palladium bullion coins covers how those markets work. If gold is your focus, our guide to which gold coins qualify for an IRA goes coin by coin, and the 1 oz American Gold Eagle page shows its specs and live melt value.

Who holds the metal, and can you keep it at home?

The custodian is the legal holder of the account's assets, and storage runs through its arrangement with a depository. You'll typically see a choice between commingled storage (your metal is pooled with other clients' identical products) and segregated storage (your specific bars and coins are kept apart), with segregated usually costing more.

Be skeptical of pitches for a "home storage IRA" or a setup where you hold the metal yourself through an LLC. These structures carry real tax risk if the IRS treats the metal as distributed. Confirm with a tax adviser and the IRS before going anywhere near one. If you'd rather keep metal at home, that's normal investing outside an IRA, and our comparison of home, bank box and vault storage walks through the trade-offs.

What does it cost?

A metals IRA stacks several layers of cost on top of the metal itself.

  • Setup fee to open the account, charged by some custodians.
  • Annual administration fee from the custodian.
  • Storage and insurance fee from the depository, flat or based on account value.
  • Dealer premium above spot on every purchase, and a spread when you sell.
  • Transaction or wire fees on buys, sells and distributions.

None of these are fixed by law, so get every fee in writing before you sign. Our explainer on premium over spot covers the dealer side in more depth.

A worked example of the cost drag

Here's an illustration with round numbers, not real quotes. Say silver is $40 an ounce and you buy 100 Silver Eagles for $46 each, a $6 premium. That's $4,600 for 100 troy ounces worth $4,000 at spot.

Now say the dealer's buyback bid is $41 per coin. If you sold the next day, you'd get $4,100, a $500 gap. Add a hypothetical $200 a year in custodian and storage fees and, after three years, you've paid about $600 in fees. Silver would need to rise roughly $11 an ounce (from $40 to about $51) just for the account to break even on the sale. You can check where spot stands now on our live silver price page.

Today's spot prices for both metals are shown here, so you can redo that maths with real figures.

Red flags when someone pitches you a metals IRA

Metals IRAs attract heavy advertising, and some sellers earn far more on the products than on the account. Watch for these.

  • Pressure to buy proof or "rare" coins. Collectible coins aren't allowed, and high-premium semi-numismatic products can lose a big share of their price the moment you buy.
  • Vague fee answers. If the salesperson can't give you the setup, annual, storage and buyback terms in writing, walk.
  • Scare tactics about bank failures or confiscation designed to rush a rollover.
  • "Free silver" promotions that are usually paid for through a higher markup on everything else.
  • No clear buyback policy. Ask how the dealer prices metal you sell back and how quickly you get paid.

Our rundown of common bullion scams covers more of these tactics.

Is it a fit for you? A quick checklist

This isn't a recommendation either way. A metals IRA tends to make more sense if most of these are true:

  • You want physical metal exposure in a tax-advantaged account and plan to hold for years, not months.
  • The account is large enough that flat yearly fees are a small share of it.
  • You're comfortable never touching the metal until a distribution.
  • You've compared at least two custodians and two dealers, with fees in writing.
  • A tax adviser has confirmed the funding route (contribution, transfer or rollover) for your situation.

If several of those don't fit, buying a modest amount of bullion in a regular taxable account may be simpler. Our beginner's guide to buying silver bullion is the place to start for that route.

Written by Editorial Team and checked against official sources under our editorial policy. Spotted an error? See our corrections policy.

Frequently asked questions

Can I put junk silver coins in a precious metals IRA?
Generally no. Pre-1965 dimes, quarters and halves are 90% silver, and IRA silver generally has to be .999 fine. Silver Eagles and Silver Maple Leafs meet the standard. Ask your IRS-approved custodian for its eligible product list before buying anything for the account.
Are Krugerrands allowed in an IRA?
Generally not. Krugerrands are 22K gold, below the .995 standard, and the specific exception that lets American Gold Eagles in doesn't cover them. If you want a coin with a full ounce of gold, the Gold Eagle, Gold Buffalo or Gold Maple Leaf are the usual eligible choices.
Can I take physical delivery of my IRA metal?
Some custodians allow an in-kind distribution, where metal is shipped to you as a distribution from the account. That can have tax consequences depending on your age and IRA type, so get the rules from your custodian and confirm the tax treatment with a tax adviser first.
How are precious metals IRAs taxed?
The account follows the tax rules of its IRA type rather than the collectibles rules that apply to coins held in a taxable account. Withdrawals, rollovers and in-kind distributions each have their own treatment, so confirm your situation with a tax adviser and the IRS before acting.

More in Bullion Investing