Guide · Gold Coins
The 1933 Gold Recall: Why Americans Gave Up Their Gold Coins
Executive Order 6102, issued in 1933, required Americans to turn in most of their gold coins, along with other gold, to the government. Private gold ownership stayed restricted for four decades and only became legal again at the end of 1974. The recall is the main reason the US stopped making gold coins for circulation and a big reason classic US gold coins carry premiums today.
What did Executive Order 6102 require?
The order, signed by President Franklin D. Roosevelt during the Great Depression, told people and businesses to deliver most of their gold coins and other gold holdings to the banking system. The broad goal was to stop gold hoarding and put the country's gold under federal control at a time when banks were failing.
The order had exceptions. Some gold could be kept, and the rules distinguished between ordinary coins and other kinds of gold holdings. We don't summarize those exceptions here because the details matter and are easy to get wrong. If you need the specifics, read the order's text through the National Archives or another official government source.
What's clear is the effect. Gold coins went from being money people carried and saved to something most Americans could no longer legally hold in quantity.
Timeline from the recall to today
- 1929: Last year of the $5 Half Eagle and the $2.50 Quarter Eagle.
- 1933: Executive Order 6102 requires most gold coins to be turned in. It's also the final year of the $10 Indian Head Eagle and the $20 Saint-Gaudens Double Eagle.
- 1971: The US stops converting dollars into gold for foreign governments, ending the gold-exchange standard.
- End of 1974: Private gold ownership becomes legal again for Americans.
- 1986: The US Mint launches the American Gold Eagle bullion coin.
- 2006: The .9999 fine American Gold Buffalo follows.
The 1971 step is a separate story about the international monetary system. Our guide to how the gold standard worked and why it ended covers it in more depth.
The chart below lets you pick a year and see how the gold price has moved since. It's a useful way to see what the decades after legalization looked like.
Gold price by year
| Year | Average | Year close | High | Low | Change |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2026 (to date) | $4,478.23 | $3,537.25 | $5,586.20 | $3,509.95 | ▼ -18.52% |
| 2025 | $3,462.96 | $4,341.10 | $4,584.00 | $2,624.01 | ▲ +64.37% |
| 2024 | $2,401.98 | $2,641.00 | $2,801.80 | $1,996.40 | ▲ +27.47% |
| 2023 | $1,953.61 | $2,071.80 | $2,152.30 | $1,810.80 | ▲ +13.45% |
| 2022 | $1,806.03 | $1,826.20 | $2,078.80 | $1,618.30 | ▼ -0.13% |
| 2021 | $1,808.75 | $1,828.60 | $1,879.50 | $1,753.00 | ▲ +17.17% |
| 2020 | $1,560.67 | $1,560.67 | $1,560.67 | $1,560.67 | ▲ +20.82% |
| 2019 | $1,291.75 | $1,291.75 | $1,291.75 | $1,291.75 | ▼ -2.97% |
| 2018 | $1,331.30 | $1,331.30 | $1,331.30 | $1,331.30 | ▲ +11.68% |
| 2017 | $1,192.10 | $1,192.10 | $1,192.10 | $1,192.10 | ▲ +8.58% |
| 2016 | $1,097.91 | $1,097.91 | $1,097.91 | $1,097.91 | ▼ -12.22% |
| 2015 | $1,250.75 | $1,250.75 | $1,250.75 | $1,250.75 | ▲ +0.52% |
| 2014 | $1,244.27 | $1,244.27 | $1,244.27 | $1,244.27 | ▼ -25.58% |
| 2013 | $1,671.85 | $1,671.85 | $1,671.85 | $1,671.85 | ▲ +1.08% |
| 2012 | $1,654.05 | $1,654.05 | $1,654.05 | $1,654.05 | ▲ +21.58% |
| 2011 | $1,360.46 | $1,360.46 | $1,360.46 | $1,360.46 | ▲ +21.69% |
| 2010 | $1,117.96 | $1,117.96 | $1,117.96 | $1,117.96 | ▲ +30.19% |
| 2009 | $858.69 | $858.69 | $858.69 | $858.69 | ▼ -3.47% |
| 2008 | $889.60 | $889.60 | $889.60 | $889.60 | ▲ +40.94% |
| 2007 | $631.17 | $631.17 | $631.17 | $631.17 | ▲ +14.79% |
| 2006 | $549.86 | $549.86 | $549.86 | $549.86 | ▲ +29.68% |
| 2005 | $424.03 | $424.03 | $424.03 | $424.03 | ▲ +2.48% |
| 2004 | $413.79 | $413.79 | $413.79 | $413.79 | ▲ +15.95% |
| 2003 | $356.86 | $356.86 | $356.86 | $356.86 | ▲ +26.77% |
| 2002 | $281.51 | $281.51 | $281.51 | $281.51 | ▲ +6.03% |
| 2001 | $265.49 | $265.49 | $265.49 | $265.49 | ▼ -6.62% |
| 2000 | $284.32 | $284.32 | $284.32 | $284.32 | ▼ -0.96% |
| 1999 | $287.08 | $287.08 | $287.08 | $287.08 | ▼ -0.70% |
| 1998 | $289.10 | $289.10 | $289.10 | $289.10 | ▼ -18.59% |
| 1997 | $355.11 | $355.11 | $355.11 | $355.11 | ▼ -11.10% |
| 1996 | $399.45 | $399.45 | $399.45 | $399.45 | ▲ +5.52% |
| 1995 | $378.55 | $378.55 | $378.55 | $378.55 | ▼ -2.15% |
| 1994 | $386.88 | $386.88 | $386.88 | $386.88 | ▲ +17.59% |
| 1993 | $329.01 | $329.01 | $329.01 | $329.01 | ▼ -7.18% |
| 1992 | $354.45 | $354.45 | $354.45 | $354.45 | ▼ -7.61% |
| 1991 | $383.64 | $383.64 | $383.64 | $383.64 | ▼ -6.45% |
| 1990 | $410.11 | $410.11 | $410.11 | $410.11 | ▲ +1.51% |
| 1989 | $404.01 | $404.01 | $404.01 | $404.01 | ▼ -15.23% |
| 1988 | $476.58 | $476.58 | $476.58 | $476.58 | ▲ +16.73% |
| 1987 | $408.26 | $408.26 | $408.26 | $408.26 | ▲ +17.49% |
| 1986 | $347.48 | $347.48 | $347.48 | $347.48 | ▲ +14.76% |
| 1985 | $302.79 | $302.79 | $302.79 | $302.79 | ▼ -18.36% |
| 1984 | $370.89 | $370.89 | $370.89 | $370.89 | ▼ -22.94% |
| 1983 | $481.29 | $481.29 | $481.29 | $481.29 | ▲ +25.29% |
| 1982 | $384.14 | $384.14 | $384.14 | $384.14 | ▼ -31.08% |
| 1981 | $557.39 | $557.39 | $557.39 | $557.39 | ▼ -17.46% |
| 1980 | $675.31 | $675.31 | $675.31 | $675.31 | ▲ +197.13% |
| 1979 | $227.28 | $227.28 | $227.28 | $227.28 | ▲ +31.24% |
| 1978 | $173.18 | $173.18 | $173.18 | $173.18 | ▲ +30.94% |
| 1977 | $132.26 | $132.26 | $132.26 | $132.26 | ▲ +0.92% |
| 1976 | $131.05 | $131.05 | $131.05 | $131.05 | ▼ -25.65% |
| 1975 | $176.27 | $176.27 | $176.27 | $176.27 | ▲ +36.44% |
| 1974 | $129.19 | $129.19 | $129.19 | $129.19 | ▲ +98.33% |
| 1973 | $65.14 | $65.14 | $65.14 | $65.14 | ▲ +42.38% |
| 1972 | $45.75 | $45.75 | $45.75 | $45.75 | ▲ +20.78% |
| 1971 | $37.88 | $37.88 | $37.88 | $37.88 | ▲ +8.41% |
| 1970 | $34.94 | $34.94 | $34.94 | $34.94 | ▼ -17.40% |
| 1969 | $42.30 | $42.30 | $42.30 | $42.30 | ▲ +19.15% |
| 1968 | $35.50 | $35.50 | $35.50 | $35.50 | ▲ +1.57% |
| 1967 | $34.95 | $34.95 | $34.95 | $34.95 | ▼ -0.51% |
| 1966 | $35.13 | $35.13 | $35.13 | $35.13 | ▲ +0.03% |
| 1965 | $35.12 | $35.12 | $35.12 | $35.12 | ▲ +0.06% |
| 1964 | $35.10 | $35.10 | $35.10 | $35.10 | ▲ +0.03% |
| 1963 | $35.09 | $35.09 | $35.09 | $35.09 | ▼ -0.40% |
| 1962 | $35.23 | $35.23 | $35.23 | $35.23 | ▼ -0.06% |
| 1961 | $35.25 | $35.25 | $35.25 | $35.25 | ▼ -0.06% |
| 1960 | $35.27 | $35.27 | $35.27 | $35.27 | ▲ +0.51% |
| 1959 | $35.09 | $35.09 | $35.09 | $35.09 | ▼ -0.03% |
| 1958 | $35.10 | $35.10 | $35.10 | $35.10 | ▲ +0.43% |
| 1957 | $34.95 | $34.95 | $34.95 | $34.95 | ▼ -0.14% |
| 1956 | $35.00 | $35.00 | $35.00 | $35.00 | ▼ -0.03% |
| 1955 | $35.01 | $35.01 | $35.01 | $35.01 | ▲ +0.14% |
| 1954 | $34.96 | $34.96 | $34.96 | $34.96 | ▲ +0.72% |
| 1953 | $34.71 | $34.71 | $34.71 | $34.71 | 0.00% |
| 1952 | $34.71 | $34.71 | $34.71 | $34.71 | 0.00% |
| 1951 | $34.71 | $34.71 | $34.71 | $34.71 | 0.00% |
| 1950 | $34.71 | $34.71 | $34.71 | $34.71 | ▲ +11.98% |
| 1949 | $31.00 | $31.00 | $31.00 | $31.00 | ▼ -8.44% |
| 1948 | $33.85 | $33.85 | $33.85 | $33.85 | 0.00% |
| 1947 | $33.85 | $33.85 | $33.85 | $33.85 | 0.00% |
| 1946 | $33.85 | $33.85 | $33.85 | $33.85 | 0.00% |
| 1945 | $33.85 | $33.85 | $33.85 | $33.85 | ▼ -0.25% |
| 1944 | $33.94 | $33.94 | $33.94 | $33.94 | 0.00% |
| 1943 | $33.94 | $33.94 | $33.94 | $33.94 | 0.00% |
| 1942 | $33.94 | $33.94 | $33.94 | $33.94 | ▲ +0.25% |
| 1941 | $33.85 | $33.85 | $33.85 | $33.85 | ▲ +5.22% |
| 1940 | $32.17 | $32.17 | $32.17 | $32.17 | ▼ -6.14% |
| 1939 | $34.28 | $34.28 | $34.28 | $34.28 | ▼ -1.69% |
| 1938 | $34.87 | $34.87 | $34.87 | $34.87 | ▲ +0.25% |
| 1937 | $34.78 | $34.78 | $34.78 | $34.78 | ▼ -0.18% |
| 1936 | $34.84 | $34.84 | $34.84 | $34.84 | 0.00% |
| 1935 | $34.84 | $34.84 | $34.84 | $34.84 | ▲ +0.47% |
| 1934 | $34.68 | $34.68 | $34.68 | $34.68 | ▲ +31.06% |
| 1933 | $26.46 | $26.46 | $26.46 | $26.46 | ▲ +27.76% |
| 1932 | $20.71 | $20.71 | $20.71 | $20.71 | ▼ -1.48% |
| 1931 | $21.02 | $21.02 | $21.02 | $21.02 | ▲ +1.77% |
| 1930 | $20.66 | $20.66 | $20.66 | $20.66 | 0.00% |
| 1929 | $20.66 | $20.66 | $20.66 | $20.66 | ▼ -0.21% |
| 1928 | $20.70 | $20.70 | $20.70 | $20.70 | ▲ +0.21% |
| 1927 | $20.66 | $20.66 | $20.66 | $20.66 | 0.00% |
| 1926 | $20.66 | $20.66 | $20.66 | $20.66 | ▲ +0.15% |
| 1925 | $20.62 | $20.62 | $20.62 | $20.62 | ▼ -0.51% |
| 1924 | $20.73 | $20.73 | $20.73 | $20.73 | ▲ +0.36% |
| 1923 | $20.66 | $20.66 | $20.66 | $20.66 | ▼ -0.16% |
| 1922 | $20.69 | $20.69 | $20.69 | $20.69 | ▲ +0.44% |
| 1921 | $20.60 | $20.60 | $20.60 | $20.60 | ▼ -0.39% |
| 1920 | $20.68 | $20.68 | $20.68 | $20.68 | ▲ +2.46% |
| 1918 | $20.18 | $20.18 | $20.18 | $20.18 | 0.00% |
| 1917 | $20.18 | $20.18 | $20.18 | $20.18 | ▼ -0.21% |
| 1916 | $20.22 | $20.22 | $20.22 | $20.22 | ▲ +0.21% |
| 1915 | $20.18 | $20.18 | $20.18 | $20.18 | ▼ -3.45% |
| 1914 | $20.90 | $20.90 | $20.90 | $20.90 | ▲ +1.23% |
| 1913 | $20.65 | $20.65 | $20.65 | $20.65 | 0.00% |
| 1912 | $20.65 | $20.65 | $20.65 | $20.65 | ▲ +0.21% |
| 1911 | $20.61 | $20.61 | $20.61 | $20.61 | 0.00% |
| 1910 | $20.61 | $20.61 | $20.61 | $20.61 | ▼ -0.21% |
| 1909 | $20.65 | $20.65 | $20.65 | $20.65 | ▼ -0.24% |
| 1908 | $20.70 | $20.70 | $20.70 | $20.70 | ▲ +0.21% |
| 1907 | $20.66 | $20.66 | $20.66 | $20.66 | ▲ +0.21% |
| 1906 | $20.61 | $20.61 | $20.61 | $20.61 | ▲ +0.03% |
| 1905 | $20.61 | $20.61 | $20.61 | $20.61 | ▼ -0.44% |
| 1904 | $20.70 | $20.70 | $20.70 | $20.70 | ▲ +0.21% |
| 1903 | $20.66 | $20.66 | $20.66 | $20.66 | ▲ +0.03% |
| 1902 | $20.65 | $20.65 | $20.65 | $20.65 | ▼ -0.24% |
| 1901 | $20.70 | $20.70 | $20.70 | $20.70 | ▲ +0.21% |
| 1900 | $20.66 | $20.66 | $20.66 | $20.66 | ▲ +0.24% |
| 1899 | $20.61 | $20.61 | $20.61 | $20.61 | ▼ -0.03% |
| 1898 | $20.61 | $20.61 | $20.61 | $20.61 | ▼ -0.21% |
| 1897 | $20.66 | $20.66 | $20.66 | $20.66 | ▼ -0.21% |
| 1896 | $20.70 | $20.70 | $20.70 | $20.70 | ▼ -0.17% |
| 1895 | $20.73 | $20.73 | $20.73 | $20.73 | ▲ +0.20% |
| 1894 | $20.69 | $20.69 | $20.69 | $20.69 | ▲ +0.18% |
| 1893 | $20.66 | $20.66 | $20.66 | $20.66 | ▼ -0.21% |
| 1892 | $20.70 | $20.70 | $20.70 | $20.70 | ▲ +0.21% |
| 1891 | $20.66 | $20.66 | $20.66 | $20.66 | ▲ +0.24% |
| 1890 | $20.61 | $20.61 | $20.61 | $20.61 | ▼ -0.21% |
| 1889 | $20.65 | $20.65 | $20.65 | $20.65 | 0.00% |
| 1888 | $20.65 | $20.65 | $20.65 | $20.65 | ▲ +0.41% |
| 1887 | $20.56 | $20.56 | $20.56 | $20.56 | ▼ -0.21% |
| 1886 | $20.61 | $20.61 | $20.61 | $20.61 | 0.00% |
| 1885 | $20.61 | $20.61 | $20.61 | $20.61 | ▲ +0.21% |
| 1884 | $20.56 | $20.56 | $20.56 | $20.56 | 0.00% |
| 1883 | $20.56 | $20.56 | $20.56 | $20.56 | ▼ -0.41% |
| 1882 | $20.65 | $20.65 | $20.65 | $20.65 | ▲ +0.83% |
| 1881 | $20.48 | $20.48 | $20.48 | $20.48 | ▼ -0.41% |
| 1880 | $20.56 | $20.56 | $20.56 | $20.56 | 0.00% |
| 1879 | $20.56 | $20.56 | $20.56 | $20.56 | ▼ -0.82% |
| 1878 | $20.73 | $20.73 | $20.73 | $20.73 | ▼ -3.74% |
| 1877 | $21.54 | $21.54 | $21.54 | $21.54 | ▼ -6.27% |
| 1876 | $22.98 | $22.98 | $22.98 | $22.98 | ▼ -3.04% |
| 1875 | $23.70 | $23.70 | $23.70 | $23.70 | ▲ +3.14% |
| 1874 | $22.98 | $22.98 | $22.98 | $22.98 | ▼ -2.34% |
| 1873 | $23.53 | $23.53 | $23.53 | $23.53 | ▲ +2.02% |
| 1872 | $23.07 | $23.07 | $23.07 | $23.07 | ▼ -0.37% |
| 1871 | $23.15 | $23.15 | $23.15 | $23.15 | ▼ -2.33% |
| 1870 | $23.70 | $23.70 | $23.70 | $23.70 | ▼ -13.73% |
| 1869 | $27.48 | $27.48 | $27.48 | $27.48 | ▼ -5.12% |
| 1868 | $28.96 | $28.96 | $28.96 | $28.96 | ▲ +1.19% |
| 1867 | $28.62 | $28.62 | $28.62 | $28.62 | ▼ -1.89% |
| 1866 | $29.17 | $29.17 | $29.17 | $29.17 | ▼ -10.53% |
| 1865 | $32.61 | $32.61 | $32.61 | $32.61 | ▼ -22.87% |
| 1864 | $42.27 | $42.27 | $42.27 | $42.27 | ▲ +41.02% |
| 1863 | $29.98 | $29.98 | $29.98 | $29.98 | ▲ +27.16% |
| 1862 | $23.57 | $23.57 | $23.57 | $23.57 | ▲ +16.56% |
| 1861 | $20.22 | $20.22 | $20.22 | $20.22 | ▼ -1.65% |
| 1860 | $20.56 | $20.56 | $20.56 | $20.56 | ▼ -1.02% |
| 1859 | $20.78 | $20.78 | $20.78 | $20.78 | ▲ +0.82% |
| 1858 | $20.61 | $20.61 | $20.61 | $20.61 | ▼ -0.61% |
| 1857 | $20.73 | $20.73 | $20.73 | $20.73 | ▼ -0.41% |
| 1856 | $20.82 | $20.82 | $20.82 | $20.82 | ▲ +0.41% |
| 1855 | $20.73 | $20.73 | $20.73 | $20.73 | ▲ +0.20% |
| 1854 | $20.69 | $20.69 | $20.69 | $20.69 | ▼ -0.20% |
| 1853 | $20.73 | $20.73 | $20.73 | $20.73 | ▼ -0.20% |
| 1852 | $20.78 | $20.78 | $20.78 | $20.78 | ▼ -0.20% |
| 1851 | $20.82 | $20.82 | $20.82 | $20.82 | ▲ +0.82% |
| 1850 | $20.65 | $20.65 | $20.65 | $20.65 | ▲ +1.25% |
| 1849 | $20.39 | $20.39 | $20.39 | $20.39 | ▼ -1.23% |
| 1848 | $20.65 | $20.65 | $20.65 | $20.65 | ▲ +1.67% |
| 1847 | $20.31 | $20.31 | $20.31 | $20.31 | ▼ -0.62% |
| 1846 | $20.44 | $20.44 | $20.44 | $20.44 | ▼ -1.03% |
| 1845 | $20.65 | $20.65 | $20.65 | $20.65 | ▲ +0.21% |
| 1844 | $20.61 | $20.61 | $20.61 | $20.61 | ▲ +1.46% |
| 1843 | $20.31 | $20.31 | $20.31 | $20.31 | ▼ -0.21% |
| 1842 | $20.35 | $20.35 | $20.35 | $20.35 | ▼ -3.81% |
| 1841 | $21.16 | $21.16 | $21.16 | $21.16 | ▼ -0.20% |
| 1840 | $21.20 | $21.20 | $21.20 | $21.20 | ▲ +0.17% |
| 1839 | $21.17 | $21.17 | $21.17 | $21.17 | ▲ +2.08% |
| 1838 | $20.73 | $20.73 | $20.73 | $20.73 | ▼ -4.12% |
| 1837 | $21.62 | $21.62 | $21.62 | $21.62 | ▲ +5.81% |
| 1836 | $20.44 | $20.44 | $20.44 | $20.44 | ▼ -0.62% |
| 1835 | $20.56 | $20.56 | $20.56 | $20.56 | ▲ +1.25% |
| 1833 | $20.31 | $20.31 | $20.31 | $20.31 | ▼ -1.44% |
| 1832 | $20.61 | $20.61 | $20.61 | $20.61 | ▼ -0.24% |
| 1831 | $20.66 | $20.66 | $20.66 | $20.66 | ▲ +2.34% |
| 1830 | $20.18 | $20.18 | $20.18 | $20.18 | ▼ -2.06% |
| 1829 | $20.61 | $20.61 | $20.61 | $20.61 | ▼ -1.19% |
| 1828 | $20.85 | $20.85 | $20.85 | $20.85 | ▼ -0.20% |
| 1827 | $20.90 | $20.90 | $20.90 | $20.90 | ▲ +0.41% |
| 1826 | $20.81 | $20.81 | $20.81 | $20.81 | ▲ +1.62% |
| 1825 | $20.48 | $20.48 | $20.48 | $20.48 | ▼ -0.59% |
| 1824 | $20.60 | $20.60 | $20.60 | $20.60 | ▲ +1.46% |
| 1823 | $20.30 | $20.30 | $20.30 | $20.30 | ▼ -3.84% |
| 1822 | $21.12 | $21.12 | $21.12 | $21.12 | ▲ +3.08% |
| 1821 | $20.49 | $20.49 | $20.49 | $20.49 | ▼ -9.99% |
| 1816 | $22.76 | $22.76 | $22.76 | $22.76 | ▼ -6.92% |
| 1815 | $24.45 | $24.45 | $24.45 | $24.45 | ▲ +10.69% |
| 1814 | $22.09 | $22.09 | $22.09 | $22.09 | ▲ +2.27% |
| 1813 | $21.60 | $21.60 | $21.60 | $21.60 | ▲ +3.20% |
| 1809 | $20.93 | $20.93 | $20.93 | $20.93 | ▲ +0.01% |
| 1808 | $20.93 | $20.93 | $20.93 | $20.93 | ▲ +4.16% |
| 1794 | $20.09 | $20.09 | $20.09 | $20.09 | 0.00% |
USD per troy ounce. Years before daily data use monthly average prices, so highs and lows are monthly averages.
How the recall shaped the gold coins you can buy now
Fewer survivors than were struck
Coins handed in during the recall left private hands. Every coin that disappeared that way shrank the pool available to collectors and investors later. That's one reason a common-date Double Eagle or $10 Eagle sells for a premium over its gold content, even in worn condition.
The end of circulating gold
After 1933 the US Mint never went back to gold coins for everyday spending. When it returned to gold in 1986, it was with bullion coins sold by weight, not coins meant to change hands at a shop counter. That's why the classic denominations ($1, $2.50, $3, $5, $10 and $20) form a closed set. For values and gold content of each, start with our guide to pre-1933 gold coins.
Later dates can be tricky
Coins struck close to the recall had less time to circulate before gold was called in. Some late dates are scarce, and a few are famous rarities with their own legal histories. If you have gold coins dated in the late 1920s or early 1930s, don't assume they're common. Check the date and mint mark in a current price guide, and have anything unusual looked at by a reputable dealer or grading service.
Worked example: what a family stash looks like today
Picture a family that quietly kept five $20 Double Eagles and four $10 Indian Head Eagles through the recall years. Here's the gold in that stash.
- Five Double Eagles × 0.9675 oz = 4.84 troy ounces.
- Four $10 Eagles × 0.48375 oz = 1.94 troy ounces.
- Total: about 6.77 troy ounces of gold, from coins with a face value of $140.
Say gold is $4,000 an ounce. The melt value would be roughly $27,090, before any collector premium. A single $10 Eagle on its own holds about $1,711.15 in gold at today's actual price.
Here's the live card for the most common recall-era coin, the Saint-Gaudens Double Eagle.
For more on these two coins, see what a $20 Double Eagle is worth and our $10 gold Eagle value guide.
Common misunderstandings about the gold recall
- "Owning old gold coins is still illegal." No. Private gold ownership has been legal again since the end of 1974.
- "Every gold coin was melted." No. Many coins survived in collections and private hands, which is why classic US gold still trades every day.
- "The order covered every scrap of gold." It covered most gold coins and certain other holdings, with exceptions. Read the official text if the detail matters to you.
- "The 1971 change was another recall." No. In 1971 the US stopped converting dollars into gold for foreign governments. That was about the international monetary system. It didn't require private citizens to hand anything in, and private ownership was still restricted until the end of 1974 anyway.
- "Recall-era coins are all rare." Most survivors are common dates priced mainly on their gold. Rarity depends on the specific date, mint mark and grade.
Owning gold coins today: the rules that do apply
The recall is history, but selling gold still comes with paperwork. The IRS treats coins and bullion as collectibles. Gains on coins held more than one year are taxed at a maximum federal rate of 28%, and short-term gains at ordinary income rates. Dealers may have to report some sales. Our page on taxes when you sell coins has the basics; confirm your situation with a tax adviser.
If you're tracking how gold has moved since ownership became legal again, our gold price history page has the long-run charts.
If you've found or inherited recall-era gold
- Don't clean the coins. Put each one in a soft holder or envelope.
- Sort them by denomination and note each date and mint mark.
- Weigh each coin and compare it with the official weight to spot fakes.
- Look up the melt value for each coin type with live prices.
- Check late-1920s and 1930s dates in a current price guide before selling.
- Get two or more quotes, and keep records of what you sell.
Written by Editorial Team and checked against official sources under our editorial policy. Spotted an error? See our corrections policy.