Guide · Bullion Investing

Bullion Scams to Avoid: 7 Tricks and How to Spot Them

Bullion Scams to Avoid: 7 Tricks and How to Spot Them

The most common bullion scams are high-pressure phone sales, coins sold at huge markups as "collectibles", fake bars and coins, and storage programs where your metal never really exists. Almost all of them share one tell: you're paying far more than the metal is worth, or you can't see and check what you bought. Knowing the live melt value before you talk to any seller is your best defense.

Here's the starting point for every deal. These cards show today's live silver and gold spot prices, the yardstick to measure any offer against.

1. The high-pressure phone or TV pitch

How it works: A friendly salesperson calls, or you call a number from a TV or radio ad. The talk is about a coming crash, bank failures or inflation. Then comes the push: prices are about to jump, this offer ends today, wire the money now.

Red flags:

  • Urgency ("only three left", "price locks for 24 hours").
  • Fear scripts about the dollar, banks or the government.
  • Reluctance to state the price per ounce or the premium over spot.
  • Requests for a wire transfer or a payment method you can't reverse.

What to do: Hang up and price the same product with two or three other dealers. A real offer will still be there tomorrow. Our guide to buying bullion online safely covers how to vet a seller.

2. The "collectible" or "exclusive" coin markup

This is the big one, because it's often legal. You ask for bullion and get steered to proof coins, special editions or "semi-numismatic" pieces described as rare, limited or protected. The coin may be real. The price is the problem.

Worked example of a markup

Say gold is $3,000 an ounce (illustrative). A salesperson sells you a coin containing one troy ounce of gold for $5,000, calling it a limited collectible. Its gold is worth $3,000. If you later sell to a dealer who pays close to melt, you might get around $2,900. You've lost about $2,100, or 42% of what you paid, with no change in the gold price.

Before buying anything sold as rare, ask for the melt value in writing and check what dealers pay for the same coin. Collector premiums can be real, but they should be verified through a reputable dealer or a current price guide, not taken from the seller's brochure.

3. The IRA switch

A company offers to move your retirement savings into a "gold IRA". Some are legitimate. Others use the IRA as a wrapper for overpriced coins or charge layers of fees.

Know the basic rules. IRS rules let an IRA hold certain bullion through a custodian: gold generally must be .995 fine (American Gold Eagles are specifically allowed) and silver .999 fine. Collectible coins are not allowed. If someone pitches rare or proof coins for your IRA, that's a warning sign. Our precious metals IRA basics page goes further; confirm any plan with an IRS-approved custodian and a tax adviser.

4. Fake bars and coins

Counterfeits show up on online marketplaces, at flea markets and in private sales. Tungsten-filled bars, plated copper rounds and copies of popular coins all exist. The lure is usually a price at or below spot.

Weight is a quick first check. Genuine pieces should match their stated weight closely:

ItemExpected weight
1 troy oz bar of pure silver or gold31.1035 g
American Silver Eagle31.103 g
American Gold Eagle, 1 oz (22K)33.931 g
American Gold Buffalo31.108 g
Kilo bar1,000 g
100 oz bar3,110.35 g

Weight alone won't catch every fake, since some are made to the correct weight. Silver and gold aren't magnetic, so a magnet that grabs a piece is a clear fail. Look out for marks like GP, GF or HGE, which signal plating rather than solid gold. For more tests, see our guides to spotting fake silver coins and spotting fake gold coins.

5. Storage programs where the metal isn't there

Some sellers offer to keep your metal for you, often at a "free" or low fee. Legitimate vaults exist. The scam version takes your money, sends statements, and never buys the metal, or pools it in a way that leaves you an unsecured creditor if the firm fails.

Before using any storage service, ask:

  • Is my metal held in my name, separately from other customers' metal?
  • Who runs the vault, and is it independent of the seller?
  • Can I visit, get an independent audit report, or take delivery on request?
  • What happens to my metal if the company closes?

Vague answers mean walk away. Our comparison of home, bank and vault storage lays out the trade-offs.

6. Too-good prices and fake payment tricks

Online listings priced below spot, especially for large bars, are a common bait. So are buyers who "overpay" with a check and ask for change back, or sellers who want gift cards or crypto. No honest dealer sells bullion below their own cost for long.

A related trick targets sellers: a buyer quotes a fair price on the phone, then finds "problems" once you arrive with your metal and offers far less. Get quotes in writing, compare them, and be ready to leave.

7. Scare stories about confiscation

Some pitches lean on history. Executive Order 6102 in 1933 did require Americans to turn in most gold coins, and private gold ownership became legal again at the end of 1974. Salespeople sometimes use that history to claim that certain products, often high-markup collectibles, are "safe" from a future recall. That's a sales line, not a legal guarantee. Treat any product pitched on fear with extra suspicion and compare its price to melt.

Your scam-proof checklist

Use the calculator below to work out the metal value of any coin or bar before you agree to a price.

Bullion value calculator

Pure metal—
Spot (melt) value—
With premium—
Per piece—
  • Know the live price: check our gold price page and silver spot before every deal.
  • Ask for the price per ounce and the premium over spot.
  • Get at least two other quotes for the same product.
  • Never wire money because of a deadline.
  • Weigh and test anything bought privately.
  • Make sure stored metal is held in your name with independent checks.
  • Keep every receipt for tax records, and confirm tax questions with an adviser.
  • If you're starting out, read our silver bullion beginner's guide before you buy.

Written by Editorial Team and checked against official sources under our editorial policy. Spotted an error? See our corrections policy.

Frequently asked questions

How do I know if a gold dealer is overcharging me?
Ask for the price per ounce and the premium over spot, then compare it with the live spot price and with quotes from two or three other dealers for the same product. If the premium is far above the others, or the seller won't state it, you are likely being overcharged.
Are gold IRA companies scams?
Not all of them. IRS rules allow certain bullion in an IRA held through an approved custodian. Problems arise when companies push collectible or proof coins, which are not allowed, or charge heavy hidden fees. Get every fee and price in writing and confirm the plan with a tax adviser.
What should I do if I think I bought fake bullion?
Stop using or reselling it and have it tested by a reputable coin shop or assayer. Keep all receipts, listings and messages. If it was bought online, contact the platform or your payment provider quickly, since buyer protection often has deadlines. You can also report fraud to your state attorney general or local police.
Is buying bullion below spot price ever legitimate?
Rarely for a retail buyer. Dealers pay close to spot or more to get their metal, so steady sales below spot usually mean fakes, stolen goods or a payment scam. Private sellers sometimes accept less for speed, but you should test the item before paying.

More in Bullion Investing