Guide · Pennies & Nickels

Flying Eagle and Copper-Nickel Indian Cents Explained

Flying Eagle and Copper-Nickel Indian Cents Explained

The Flying Eagle cent is a small US one-cent coin made of 88% copper and 12% nickel, weighing 4.67 grams. The same copper-nickel alloy continued on the early Indian Head cents through 1864, when the Mint switched to a lighter bronze cent. Their metal is worth only a few cents, but nearly all surviving pieces sell to collectors for well above that.

What makes these cents different?

Pick one up next to a wheat cent and you'll notice right away. Copper-nickel cents are thicker and heavier, and the nickel gives them a paler, tan-to-light-brown color instead of the reddish brown of bronze. Some collectors call them "white cents" for that reason.

FeatureCopper-nickel cents (1856–1864)Bronze Indian cents (1864–1909)
DesignsFlying Eagle, then Indian HeadIndian Head
Weight4.67 g3.11 g
Composition88% copper, 12% nickel95% copper, 5% tin and zinc
LookThicker, palerThinner, reddish to dark brown

The live table below puts the two Indian-era alloys next to a wheat cent so you can compare today's melt values.

CoinYearsMetal contentMelt value× face
Flying Eagle & Indian Head Copper-Nickel Cent1856–18644.67 g · 88% copper $0.06016.0×
Indian Head Penny (bronze)1864–19093.11 g · 95% copper $0.03723.7×
Lincoln Wheat Penny1909–19583.11 g · 95% copper $0.03723.7×

Melt value = metal content × today’s spot price. It is not what a dealer pays (usually less) or a collector’s price (often more).

A short history of the copper-nickel cent

Before these coins, America's cent was a much larger copper coin. The copper-nickel small cent replaced it with something lighter and easier to carry, and the nickel content made the alloy harder.

The Flying Eagle design came first and lasted only a short time. It was hard to strike well in the tough copper-nickel alloy, so the Mint moved to the Indian Head design while keeping the same 4.67-gram, 88/12 composition. In 1864 the cent changed again to the thinner bronze alloy, which ran until the Lincoln cent arrived in 1909.

That makes 1864 a two-metal year, a lot like 1982 for Lincoln cents. Both copper-nickel and bronze Indian cents carry the 1864 date. For the full run of penny alloys from 1856 to 2025, see our guide to penny composition by year.

How to identify one in your hand

Check the design

A Flying Eagle cent shows an eagle in flight on the front with the date below. The early Indian Head cents show a figure of Liberty wearing a feathered headdress. If you see an eagle, you're holding a copper-nickel coin. If you see the Indian Head, keep going.

Check the date

Indian Head cents dated before 1864 are copper-nickel. Dates after 1864 are bronze. An 1864 can be either.

Weigh it

A scale that reads to 0.1 gram settles it. Around 4.6 to 4.7 g means copper-nickel. Around 3.1 g means bronze. Wear can shave a little off, but the gap of more than 1.5 grams is hard to miss.

Melt value: a worked example

Here's the metal math, using round example prices of $4.50 a pound for copper and $7 a pound for nickel. Prices change, so treat this as an illustration.

  • Copper: 4.67 g × 88% = 4.11 g, or about 0.0091 lb. At $4.50 that's roughly 4.1 cents.
  • Nickel: 4.67 g × 12% = 0.56 g, or about 0.0012 lb. At $7 that's roughly 0.9 cents.
  • Total: about 5 cents of metal in a one-cent coin.

At today's actual prices, one copper-nickel cent holds about $0.0601 in metal. Our copper-nickel cent page tracks it live, and the card below shows the same figure with full specs.

That number is a floor, not a price. These coins are well over 150 years old, and collectors pay for that history.

What actually drives collector value

We don't publish dollar figures for individual dates, because they move with the market and depend heavily on grade. What we can tell you is which factors matter:

  1. Date. Some years were made in smaller numbers or survive in fewer examples, and the very earliest Flying Eagle pieces are especially sought after.
  2. Condition. Sharp details on the eagle's feathers or Liberty's headdress, with no heavy wear, add a lot. How grading works explains the scale dealers use.
  3. Surfaces. Original, uncleaned color is preferred. A cleaned coin often sells for much less, as our guide to coin cleaning mistakes explains.
  4. Varieties and errors. Doubled dates, repunched numbers and similar quirks can matter to specialists.
  5. Authenticity. Scarce early dates attract fakes and altered dates. Anything that looks valuable deserves a reputable dealer's eye or a grading service.

For current prices, use a recent price guide or ask a reputable dealer. If you also have later bronze cents, our Indian Head penny value guide covers those.

Can you melt them?

Even if you wanted to, the answer is no. Under 31 CFR Part 82, melting US 1-cent coins is prohibited except in narrow cases such as crafts and incidental recycling, and the only coins specifically exempted are the 1942 to 1945 silver war nickels. With collector value far above melt, there's no reason to try. The pillar guide on saving copper pennies covers the law in more detail.

Found one? Do this next

  • Handle it by the edges and don't clean it.
  • Weigh it to confirm copper-nickel (about 4.67 g).
  • Note the date and any doubling or odd features under a magnifier.
  • Store it in an inert holder away from damp air.
  • Compare against a current price guide, then get a dealer or grading service opinion if the date or condition looks promising.

Written by Editorial Team and checked against official sources under our editorial policy. Spotted an error? See our corrections policy.

Frequently asked questions

What is a Flying Eagle cent made of?
A Flying Eagle cent is 88% copper and 12% nickel and weighs 4.67 grams. The same alloy was used for the early Indian Head cents through 1864. The nickel gives these coins a paler color than later bronze cents.
How much is a Flying Eagle cent worth in metal?
Its copper and nickel are typically worth a few cents, and you can see the live figure on our copper-nickel cent page. Nearly every surviving Flying Eagle cent sells to collectors for more than that, depending on date and condition, so check a current price guide.
Why is my Indian Head penny heavier than others?
If it weighs about 4.67 grams, it's a copper-nickel Indian cent from the years before the 1864 switch to bronze. Later bronze Indian cents weigh 3.11 grams. The year 1864 was struck in both alloys, so weigh any 1864 cent to see which one you have.
Should I clean an old Flying Eagle cent?
No. Cleaning removes original surface and leaves marks that collectors and graders can spot, which usually lowers the value sharply. Store it as found in an inert holder and let a dealer or grading service judge it.

More in Pennies & Nickels