Guide · Gold Coins
$2.50 Quarter Eagles and $1 Gold Dollars: Gold Content and Value
A $1 gold dollar holds 0.04837 troy ounces of pure gold, worth about $171.14 at today's spot price, and a $2.50 Quarter Eagle holds 0.12094 ounces, about $427.84. That melt figure is the floor. Because these small coins are old and popular with collectors, most of them sell for more than their gold, sometimes a lot more.
So the honest answer has two parts: what the gold is worth, which you can work out to the cent, and what a collector will pay on top, which depends on date, mint mark and condition.
What are these two little coins?
Both were struck before the 1933 gold recall, and both are 90% gold and 10% copper, the same alloy as the big $20 pieces. They're just much smaller.
| $1 gold dollar | $2.50 Quarter Eagle | |
|---|---|---|
| Years | 1849–1889 | Liberty 1840–1907, Indian 1908–1929 |
| Weight | 1.672 g | 4.18 g |
| Composition | 90% gold, 10% copper | 90% gold, 10% copper |
| Pure gold | 0.04837 troy oz | 0.12094 troy oz |
| Melt today | $171.14 | $427.84 |
The gold dollar is the lightest coin in the whole US gold series. Hold one and it feels like a sequin with a date on it. The Quarter Eagle is a bit larger, but still smaller than a modern nickel in weight terms: 4.18 grams against the nickel's 5 grams.
The Liberty and Indian Head Quarter Eagles carry identical gold content. Design changes nothing about melt. You'll find specs and live values on our gold dollar page, the Liberty Quarter Eagle page and the Indian Head Quarter Eagle page.
How much gold value is in each one?
The math is the same formula used for every coin: weight × fineness × spot price.
Worked example with round numbers
Say gold is $4,000 a troy ounce. This is an example, not today's price.
- Gold dollar: 1.672 g × 0.90 = 1.505 g of gold. That's 0.04837 ozt × $4,000 = $193.48.
- Quarter Eagle: 4.18 g × 0.90 = 3.762 g of gold. That's 0.12094 ozt × $4,000 = $483.76.
Put another way, it takes roughly 20 gold dollars, or about 8 Quarter Eagles, to add up to one troy ounce of gold. That's why small gold is an expensive way to own metal by weight: you're buying a lot of coins, and each one carries its own collector premium.
The live table below shows today's melt for both Quarter Eagle designs and the gold dollar side by side. The numbers update with the gold price.
| Coin | Years | Metal content | Melt value | × face |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1849–1889 | 0.0484 oz gold | $171.14 | 171.1× | |
| 1840–1907 | 0.1210 oz gold | $427.84 | 171.1× | |
| 1908–1929 | 0.1210 oz gold | $427.84 | 171.1× |
Melt value = metal content × today’s spot price. It is not what a dealer pays (usually less) or a collector’s price (often more).
Why collectors usually pay more than melt
Very few of these coins get melted today, and for good reason. A worn, common-date gold dollar is still a 19th-century gold coin, and there's steady demand from people building type sets of US gold. That demand puts a premium on top of the metal.
The premium grows with:
- Date and mint mark. Some years and branch mints made far fewer coins. Check the mint mark before you assume a coin is common; our guide to reading mint marks shows where to look.
- Condition. Sharp detail and original surfaces matter more on tiny coins, where wear erases design quickly.
- Problems. Holes, solder marks from jewelry use, scratches and cleaning all cut collector value, sometimes down close to melt.
We won't put a number on that premium here, because it moves with the market and varies enormously by date. A current price guide, a reputable dealer or a grading service is the right source for a specific coin. If you want the background on how condition is judged, start with coin grading basics.
If you have one of these, here's what to do
If it came out of an old jewelry box
Small gold coins were popular in pendants, bracelets and cufflinks. Look for a loop, a bezel or solder marks on the edge. An ex-jewelry coin often trades nearer melt, since collectors avoid damaged pieces. Don't try to grind off the solder yourself.
If it looks too perfect
Gold dollars and Quarter Eagles have been widely counterfeited, partly because their small size makes fakes hard to judge by eye. A coin that's too light, too shiny or slightly off in color deserves a closer look. Our guide on spotting fake gold coins walks through weight and other checks.
If it's a modern "gold dollar"
A Sacagawea or Presidential dollar is gold-colored brass, not gold. If your coin is dated 2000 or later and is the size of a Susan B. Anthony dollar, read whether golden dollars contain gold before you get your hopes up.
If you have a small pile of them
Sort by denomination, then by date and mint mark. Note anything with damage. Get the common pieces quoted together and any scarcer dates looked at one by one.
Mistakes that cost people money
- Selling at melt without checking dates. A buyer offering a flat per-coin price may be getting scarce pieces for the price of common ones.
- Cleaning the coin. A polished gold dollar looks bright to you and damaged to a collector. Leave it as is.
- Weighing on a kitchen scale. Most kitchen scales can't resolve the difference between 1.672 g and a slightly light fake. Use a scale that reads to 0.01 g.
- Treating these like bullion. If you only want gold by weight, a modern bullion coin is a more direct route. Small pre-1933 gold is a collector market first.
Quick checklist before you sell
- Confirm the denomination, date and mint mark.
- Weigh it to 0.01 g and compare with 1.672 g or 4.18 g.
- Look up today's melt so you know the floor.
- Check a current price guide for your date and grade.
- Get at least two quotes, and ask each buyer whether they're paying for gold or for the coin.
For the bigger picture on old US gold, including the $5, $10 and $20 coins, see our guide to pre-1933 gold coin values.
Written by Editorial Team and checked against official sources under our editorial policy. Spotted an error? See our corrections policy.