Guide · Selling & Buying Coins

Is It Worth Getting Coins Graded?

Is It Worth Getting Coins Graded?

Getting a coin graded is worth it when the expected increase in sale price is clearly bigger than the total cost of grading, shipping and insurance. That usually means scarcer dates, high-condition coins, valuable gold and suspected errors that need authentication. For worn junk silver, common bullion and most circulated coins, grading costs more than it adds.

The decision is really a bit of arithmetic plus an honest look at the coin. Here's how to run both.

What you're paying for when you grade a coin

A third-party service such as PCGS or NGC checks that the coin is genuine, assigns a grade and seals it in a labeled holder. Buyers trust that label, so a graded coin is easier to sell, especially online or to someone who can't inspect it in hand. The basics of the grade scale are in our guide to coin grading basics.

Your total cost usually includes:

  • The grading fee, which typically varies with the coin's declared value and the turnaround you choose.
  • Membership or submission fees, depending on the service and how you submit.
  • Insured shipping to the grader and the return shipping and insurance.
  • Your time, plus weeks or more without the coin.

Fees change, so check the service's current fee schedule before you decide. We don't quote them here because they'd go stale.

The break-even test

Ask two questions: what would this coin sell for raw (ungraded), and what would it realistically sell for once graded at the grade you expect? If the difference doesn't comfortably cover your total cost, don't submit.

Worked example

Here's an illustration with round, made-up numbers. Say your all-in cost to grade one coin, including fees and shipping both ways, comes to $60.

Coin 1: worn common MorganCoin 2: sharp better-date Morgan
Raw valueAbout melt: $31 at $40 silverSay $150 from dealer quotes
Expected value if gradedStill about meltSay $260 if it grades as hoped
Gain from gradingAbout $0$110
Minus grading cost$60$60
Net resultLose about $60Gain about $50

Coin 2 looks like a win, but only if it gets the grade you hoped for. If it comes back one step lower, or is flagged as cleaned, the gain could vanish. Build in a margin for that.

For the melt floor, check today's figures for the coins most often submitted:

CoinYearsMetal contentMelt value× face
Morgan Silver Dollar1878–1904, 19210.7735 oz silver $31.8031.8×
Peace Silver Dollar1921–19350.7735 oz silver $31.8031.8×
$20 Saint-Gaudens Double Eagle1907–19330.9675 oz gold $3,422.31171.1×
$20 Liberty Head Double Eagle1850–19070.9675 oz gold $3,422.31171.1×

Melt value = metal content × today’s spot price. It is not what a dealer pays (usually less) or a collector’s price (often more).

Coins that are often worth grading

  • Scarce dates and mint marks in better condition. Check our list of coins worth checking before selling for melt.
  • Coins that look uncirculated, with full luster and few marks, where a single grade step can move the price.
  • Pre-1933 US gold coins in nicer condition, where authenticity is also a concern for buyers.
  • Suspected errors, including any 1943 copper-colored cent that doesn't stick to a magnet. Most are fakes, so authentication is the main point. See error coin basics.
  • Coins you plan to sell online, where buyers can't hold the coin and a trusted label reduces disputes.

Coins that usually aren't worth grading

  • Worn 90% silver dimes, quarters and halves, which dealers buy by the dollar face.
  • 40% Kennedy halves and war nickels in average circulated condition.
  • Common modern bullion such as Silver Eagles bought to stack.
  • Cleaned, scratched, holed or corroded coins. Many services won't assign a regular grade to problem coins.
  • Wheat pennies and other common copper coins in typical circulated grades.

What if the grade comes back lower than you hoped?

This is the risk most first-time submitters underestimate. You can't choose the grade, and graders see things you missed: faint hairlines from an old cleaning, a rim bump hidden by a flip, wear on a high point that looked fine under a kitchen light.

Possible outcomes, roughly from best to worst:

  • The grade you expected or better. The plan works.
  • One step lower. On many coins that wipes out most of the expected gain.
  • A "details" grade. Services may note problems like cleaning or damage instead of giving a regular grade. These coins usually sell at a discount to problem-free ones.
  • Not authentic. Painful, but at least you know before you try to sell it.

The fee is spent either way. That's why the break-even test should only include coins with a comfortable margin.

Downsides of slabbed coins people forget

  • A sealed holder is bulkier to store than a coin in a flip or tube.
  • Some collectors prefer certain services and pay less for coins from others.
  • Breaking a coin out of its holder to regrade it means paying again.
  • A graded common coin doesn't sell for more just because it's in plastic. Buyers pay for the grade on the label, not the label itself.

If you have one of these situations

If you inherited a large collection

Don't send everything. Have a reputable dealer or appraiser identify the handful of coins that would benefit, and sell the rest raw. A paid appraisal can make sense for an estate; our guide to how coin appraisals work explains the options.

If you're selling soon to a local dealer

A good dealer can grade a coin by eye and price it raw. For mid-value coins, the time and cost of grading may not beat a fair raw offer.

If you're keeping the coin long term

Grading also protects the coin in a sealed holder and documents it for heirs. That's a reasonable non-financial reason, as long as you accept the cost.

Ways to cut the risk

  1. Get a dealer's opinion on the likely grade before you submit.
  2. Choose a widely accepted service, since its grades carry more weight with buyers.
  3. Pick the slowest turnaround you can tolerate, which is usually the cheapest.
  4. Pack and insure properly. Our tips on shipping coins safely apply here.
  5. Never clean a coin before submitting it.

Your quick decision checklist

  • Is the coin worth meaningfully more than melt in its current condition? If not, skip grading.
  • Would the expected graded price beat the raw price by more than your total cost, with room to spare?
  • Is authenticity in doubt? Grading may be worth it for that alone.
  • Are you selling online? A trusted label helps.
  • Still unsure? Get a raw offer first, then decide. The broader selling steps are in our pillar on how to sell old coins, and live specs for every series are on our coin melt value pages.

Written by Editorial Team and checked against official sources under our editorial policy. Spotted an error? See our corrections policy.

Frequently asked questions

How long does coin grading take?
Turnaround depends on the grading service, the service level you pay for and how busy they are. Faster tiers cost more. Allow extra time for shipping in both directions and check the service's current posted turnaround times before you submit.
Can a graded coin be regraded?
Yes. Owners sometimes resubmit a coin, either to the same service or a different one, hoping for a higher grade. Each submission costs money and the result can be the same or lower, so it only makes sense when the possible gain is large.
Does grading make junk silver easier to sell?
Not really. Junk silver is bought by dealers based on face value and silver content, and they don't pay extra for grading on worn common coins. The cost of grading would almost always exceed any benefit.
Will grading tell me if my coin is fake?
Major grading services check authenticity as part of the process and generally won't grade a coin they believe is counterfeit. That makes grading useful for coins often faked, such as gold coins and famous error coins.

More in Selling & Buying Coins